15 Best Colored Mascaras Of 2024 To Make Your Eyelashes Pop!
Add some color and character to your eyes anywhere with these bright formulations.
Lorrie Pearson is a professional makeup artist who has been creating her signature natural makeup looks for 20+ years. She began her career working behind the cosmetics counter that helped her strengthen her skills in application. Ms. Pearson received her esthetics license from the Catherine Hinds Institute of Esthetics where she taught skincare and makeup.
Read full bio of Lorrie Pearson
Experience: 2 yearsSrijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world.
Read full bio of Srijita De
Experience: 3 yearsRajeshwari is a dedicated fitness and lifestyle enthusiast, deeply committed to enhancing our readers’ well-being and vitality. She has a master’s degree in Journalism & Mass Communication from the University of Calcutta.
Read full bio of Rajeshwari Das
Experience: 3 yearsSrijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant.
Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury
Image: Shutterstock
There is something about using the best-colored mascaras that can make your eyes stand out at all times. If you are a makeup enthusiast, you must have experimented with colored eyeliners and eye shadows, but now is the time to elevate to the level of mascaras. We are grateful to the person who thought of making a product that will make your eyelashes firm and long. Now that your batting eyelid looks perfect, it’s time you add a little color magic to it. Black mascaras are perfect for regular wear, but no one wants to look just ordinary when it comes to a celebration, right? Opting for statement-making, vibrant colors like green and burgundy can uplift your eyes instantly and help you upgrade your look instantly. Here are 15 mascaras with gorgeous colors crafted especially for your party needs.
In This Article
Best Colored Mascaras For 2024!
1. L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara – Deep Burgundy
Wine never looked this fine before! This deep burgundy voluminous mascara by Loreal Paris is bold, beautiful, and intoxicating with a chicer appeal and flattering eyelash enhancement results. Several reviewers attest that it sweeps on the lashes like butter while evenly coating every strand from the root to the tip. Plus, it guarantees to make your lashes look 5 times fuller, healthier, and gorgeous! Ideal for fans of the color or those who want to intensify their everyday look, the formula also contains panthenol and ceramide-R that nourish the lashes under the luxuriously smooth coat. Do you think you can handle it?
- Ultra-conditioning and lightweight formula
- Makes lashes softer and smoother
- Waterproof and flake-free mascara
- Volumizing bristled brush ensures longer and thicker lashes
- Ideal for creating bold and dramatic eye makeup looks
- Suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers
- It may clump.
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
More than 77,645 customers have given the product positive reviews on Amazon.
2. Best Oil-Free Formula:blinc Tubing Mascara – Deep Green
No rain, sweat, or tears can ruin your eye makeup if you have a coat of blinc’s Tubing Mascara! Break free from the cliché black this season, and give green a chance to shine on your eyes. The only color that’ll make others envy, and your lashes look gorgeously longer and fuller, the formula is unlike anything you’ve tried before. Forming tiny water-resistant tubes on the strands that stick on like a magnet, it guarantees to last all day long without smudging. A must-try for workaholics, gym enthusiasts, and those who dislike touch ups, give this deep green a sweep to enhance your eye color.
- Oil-free formula
- Vegan and cruelty-free product
- Adds volume and makes lash look longer
- Clump-free, run-proof, and fade-proof mascara
- It glides smoothly and wipes off easily with water.
- Ideal for those with sensitive skin or eyes, and contact lens wearers.
- Expensive
- It takes longer to dry.
Pro Tip3. Best Easy-To-Remove:Maybelline Great Lash Mascara – Royal Blue
So royal, your eyes will steal the scene in a blink! Beauties, here’s a mascara that’ll transform your bold lashes with a starry and sensational tint of blue. Infused with a volume-building element, watch your eyelashes look fuller, longer, and every bit luxurious with every sweep. A great option to pair with all your evening and party OOTDs, you can also wear it during the day for a trendy look. This ophthalmologist-tested mascara glides smoothly, is easy-to-remove, and also guarantees to condition your lashes as it thickens. Still, want to stick to your classic old mascara? If you are still unsure, check out this honest review detailing a tester’s experience with the product.
- No-clump and no-glob formula
- Hypoallergenic and waterproof
- Delivers a full lash look instantly
- Safe and suitable for contact lens wearers
- Light pigment
4. Best Smudge-Proof Formula:100% PURE Fruit Pigmented Mascara – Blackberry
This mascara packs a fruity punch — not kidding! With no toxic ingredients, fragrances, or colorants, 100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Mascara guarantees a deliciously fruity coat on your lashes. Formulated with blackberry and blueberry extracts (hence the color name!), it conditions the lashes while making them look longer and fuller instantly. And since there are no toxic petrochemicals involved, the color that you see is all-natural fruit, not coal tar! Interesting, right? Other than this, its pigmented formula guarantees to strengthen weak lashes and smells like blackberries too. It is also not tested on animals, making it an ideal cruelty-free option. Indulge, already! Click this video to learn more about a tester’s experience with the product.
- Cruelty-free product
- Promotes lash growth
- Made of 100% pure ingredients
- Smudge-proof, long-lasting, and non-irritating formula
- Infused with wheat protein, oat protein, and B5 vitamin
- Suitable to create intense and dramatic makeup looks
- Pricey
- It’s not waterproof.
5. Best Clump-Free Option:Golden Rose Perfect Lashes Mascara – Blue
If you are going to ditch the black, let it be for this blue! Other than being a quick-drying formula that makes it a must-try for those who are always on the go, it is also a great mascara for blue eyes. This mascara enhances your lashes and makes your eyes the star of your makeup. Numerous reviewers vouch for this volume-building brush with dense bristles as it also separates the lashes and coats them evenly and luxuriously. Promising a false eyelash look within a few sweeps, get ready to be hooked to this magic blue stick instantly.
- Soft and smooth bright mascara
- Adds intensity and drama
- Easy to apply and remove
- Clump-free, flake-free, and smudge-proof
- Not recommended for sensitive eyes
- It may feel slightly heavy on the lashes.
6. Best Long-Lasting Option:Pacifica Beauty Aquarian Gaze Mascara – Deep Blue
Go blue, the vegan way! For all those who are looking for an all-natural and colored mascara, this one might suit your lash needs. Formulated with enriching ingredients such as kelp extract, coconut oil, and vitamin B, it feels more like a spa than mascara on the lashes! And besides this, multiple reviews on online forums attest that the dense bristles ensure to coat every strand with a thick layer, thus adding a stunning volume instantly. Want more? The vegan brush is designed to comb and separate the strands gently, so you don’t have to worry about clumping! Try it.
- Cruelty-free product
- Natural mineral and water-resistant mascara
- Long-lasting, nourishing, and conditioning formula
- Makes lashes look longer and eyes look bigger
- Free from parabens, mineral oil, petroleum, phthalates, silicone, and more
- Subtle pigment
- It may flake.
7. NYX Professional Makeup Color Mascara – Purple
Is purple too bold for you? But what if we tell you that this tint without being undeniably extra will add an oomph factor to your eyes and vibe? Yep, get ready to step out of your comfort “black or brown mascara” zone and set trends with this purple hue. A great way to show your chicer side without being loud and sparkly, NYX color lengthening mascara offers an intense color payoff and can be used to create an ombre effect on the tips too. Use it alone or with your everyday mascara, it also claims to add a desirable volume on your lashes. Ethically-conscious reviewers also recommend this product as it is free of animal testing. Are you curious how gorgeous it will look? Give it a try!
- Packed with intense pigments
- Delivers an intense and trendy look
- Adds length and coats every strand
- Ideal for everyday or no makeup looks
- It may clump.
"This NYX's colored mascara is easy to apply. I often layer two to three coats to achieve the desired intensity. The formula does not flake or clump, which makes the product great for both daily and occasional use. It is a great pick to enhance both lash and brow color."
Pro Tip8. Best Ophthalmologist-Tested:COVERGIRL Total Tease Mascara – Deep Blue
Are you looking for a drugstore colored mascara? Then you must try Covergirl’s Total Tease Mascara. Widely known for the brush plus comb combination bristles, it not only adds volume but separates them gently and ensures all the strands are coated evenly! Plus, it is richly-formulated with a polymer thickening complex that claims to define the natural curve of the lashes beautifully to achieve bold runway looks. And since it is a colored mascara, watch it tease and be flirty every time you flutter your dramatic lashes during the day!
- Instantly adds 500% more volume
- Clump-free, smudge-free, and lash amplifying lacquer
- No-mess experience and waterproof
- Ophthalmologist-tested and safe for contact lens wearers
- It may flake.
9. Best Quick Drying Product:GL-Turelifes Handaiyan Mascara – Crimson
Wow-worthy lashes, now in seconds! With Handaiyan Mascara in your statement makeup kit, you don’t need a liner or eyeshadow to make your eyes pop instantly. Bold, bright, and insanely gorgeous, the blazing color of this unique mascara will make your lashes stand out without looking extra or gaudy. If you have auburn tresses or hazel eyes, then you’ll love the look this mascara will deliver! Also, the skinny brush with micro bristles is easy-to-use and ensures all strands are coated evenly. Ideal to brush both upper and bottom lashes, it can be used alone or with other colors to create a multi-colored look. Try it— we dare you!
- Curls lashes smoothly and evenly
- Lightweight and easy to remove
- Makes lashes look longer and thicker
- Quick-drying and long-lasting formula
- Smudge-proof, water-proof, and sweat-proof
- Suitable for professionals and beginners
- Ideal for creating every day, party, festival and Halloween makeup looks
- It may flake.
10. Best For Contact Lens Wearer:Pure Ziva Mascara – Royal Blue
Go beyond the clichés and conventional colors, and sweep on this captivating blue mascara this season! Bold and mesmerizing at the same time, watch all eyes follow yours the moment you enter the room. A must-try color mascara for blue eyes or those who dare to risk and explore beauty trends, this high-quality mascara is also made of all-natural ingredients. It is also not tested on animals, making it ideal for ethically-conscious consumers. And since the brand claims to make your eyes pop instantly, who needs accessories or intense eye makeup when you have this fascinating blue to flaunt and flutter your colored lash extensions? Try this bright-colored mascara with the non-clumping formula to witness a stunning glow-up!
- Subtly highlights the eyes
- Clump-free and easy-to-apply formula
- Ophthalmologist-tested and cruelty-free
- Suitable for those who wear contact lenses
- Expensive
- It may flake after a few hours.
11. Christina’s Natural Qualities Luminous Lash Mascara – Glorious Gold
Staying true to its name, this gold tint will glorify your eyes with a spell-binding metallic sheen! And if you have blonde eyelashes, then bless your stars for this gold is all you need to make a show-stopping entry anywhere, anytime. The formula other than enhancing your golden or yellowish-golden lashes will add a “Look At Me” charm to your eyes that might trigger some wows and praises. And the best part is, this mascara is made of 100% natural ingredients, herbal extracts, and ground minerals. Vegan makeup lovers, explore!
- Suitable for all skin tones
- Intense metallic gold mascara
- Long-lasting and hypoallergenic
- Soy-free and cruelty-free product
- Quick-drying, water-resistant, and non-irritating formula
- It is safe for normal, dry, oily, and combination skin.
- Expensive
12. Best Non-Irritating Formula:Qibest Volumizing Mascara – A2
There is something alluring about lavender that makes it a likable color, so there is no reason why one shouldn’t try it as a mascara! We mean, look how soft, pure, and pretty the color is, we bet it’ll set trends as a summer and spring mascara color too. So, if you are looking for new and unconventional waterproof mascara colors to explore, you might as well try Qibest Volumizing Mascara. With its unique fiber bristles, you can not only add volume but also curl and define the shape of your lashes effortlessly. This lash care product is worth a try.
- Suitable for all skin types
- Makes lashes look longer
- Flexible and lightweight formula
- Quick-drying and waterproof
- Long-lasting and non-irritating
- Ideal for daily wear, makeup schools, Halloween, cosplays, models, etc
- It may clump.
13. Best Shimmery Finish:Nature’s Brands Bella Mari Mascara – Green
If you think green mascara is better off for Halloween, then you haven’t tried the right tint yet! Like this one, for instance, infused with shimmer will add a stunning glow to your eyes. More like sweeping on magic dust than mascara, it leaves a subtle tint that’ll make anyone fall in love with your eye makeup instantly. And if that wasn’t enough, this mascara is also 100% chemical-free! Formulated with all-natural ingredients, the bristles ensure all the lashes are combed and coated evenly. Ethically-conscious reviewers also recommend this product as it does not condone animal testing. Give it a sweep, this season!
- Delivers a silky-smooth finish
- Vegan and cruelty-free product
- Infused with natural and earth minerals
- Weightless, fragrance-free, and clump-free
- Free from paraben, preservatives, alcohol, gluten, soy, etc.
- Expensive
- It may flake.
- You may have to touchup after a few hours.
14. Best Lash Thickening Product:Clinique Chubby Lash Fattening Mascara – Portly Plum
Fashion your colossal lashes with this mascara and an oversized bristled brush! Get ready to be wowed by your own eyes as this volumizing mascara guarantees to make your lashes look double the natural size. Are you dealing with thin or weak lashes lately? Then look no further, for this plum-colored formula will not only thicken your lashes visibly but also add intensity and drama to your gorgeous eyes. Promising a stunning plum color that you can explore during the day or while on a getaway, grab your Chubby Lash Fattening Mascara by Clinique today.
- Luxurious and smooth formula
- Delivers a bold and rich layer
- Fragrance-free, allergy-tested, and ophthalmologist-tested
- Ideal plum colored mascara for brown eyes, dark brown eyes and light brown eyes
- It may be clumpy.
15. Best For Multi-Dimensional Look:Almay Intense i-Color Volumizing Mascara – Sapphire
Lastly, this volumizing colored mascara for sensitive eyes! And this is no ordinary formula, Almay Intense i-Color Mascara is infused with eye-brightening and enhancing crystals to give your lashes a multi-dimensional look. Besides this, the brush is designed to boost volume and coat every lash with a thick layer evenly. Just the gem you need to make your eyes shine within seconds! Try this gorgeous color, which is ophthalmologist-tested and won’t irritate your eyes all day too. Learn more about a reviewer’s experience with the product in this video.
- Dermatologist-tested and hypoallergenic
- Ophthalmologist tested
- Long-lasting, flake-free, and clump-free
- Lashes look 2 times thicker and defined
- Suitable for contact lens wearers
- It will make eyes pop instantly with glitter.
- It might clump slightly.
Curious to try them all, aren’t you? There you go, those were the 15 best-colored mascaras of 2024 that you must not miss. Do you need more assistance with buying the best-colored mascara? Read the buying guide below.
Buying Guide – Best colored Mascara
How To Choose The Best Colored Mascara For Your Eyes?
Though choosing a colored mascara is a gutsy thing in itself, we bet you won’t be disappointed if you choose the right formula and color for your eyes. Look out for these features:
- Pigment: Since it’s a colored mascara, the pigment is indispensable. Available in subtle to highly pigmented options, choose a mascara that will not only enhance your iris color but also suit the skin tone and type.
- Volumizing: Volume is a mascara thing. Whether you are choosing a regular or colored mascara, it must deliver volume to make your lashes look fuller and healthier. So, if you want your eyes to look bigger and noticeable, then choose a mascara that guarantees a volumizing effect.
- Stay Power: It goes without saying that mascara should last long. Also, it should be waterproof, unless you don’t mind showing up with smeared makeup! Ideally, a long-lasting and waterproof colored mascara is the best combination to have in your collection.
- Bristled Brush: Choosing the right bristled brush matters too. In fact, it is the brush that helps you get the right mascara look. So, choose one that along with adding volume and length, also combs, separates, and coats every strand from the root to the tip.
- Ease To Remove: A colored mascara should be easy to apply and remove as well. Given how delicate the skin is around that area, you wouldn’t like to tug or use harsh mascara removers on the lashes. So, before choosing a colored mascara, check if the formula is hassle-free and easy-to-remove.
Makeup artist Lorrie Pearson quips, “Colored mascaras are a great way to not only add a pop of color to your eyes but can also add depth to the shadows you have applied. Colored mascaras are now available in almost any color you can imagine. The possibilities to create a variety of looks are limitless.”
How To Wear Colored Mascara?
There are three ways to do it. You can either wear it alone, with primer to intensify the pigment or as a top coat over black mascara. Ideally, experts suggest that you pair colored mascara with an eyeshadow or eyeliner of the same color for a powerful effect. However, if you want to keep it subtle, then sweep on your lashes just like your regular mascara— going from roots to tips. Here are some simple steps for beginners:
- Before you apply mascara, comb the lashes.
- Next, apply mascara by gently combing and coating the color on the lash from root to tip.
- Do not wait for the first coat to dry before applying the second coat.
- Make sure every strand is layered with a coat.
- Also, wait for the mascara to dry before you proceed to other eye makeup steps.
The Bottom Line
If you are a makeup enthusiast, you might have come across colored mascaras that are put on to elevate your eye makeup. These mascaras offer an enhanced beauty and are perfect for a glammed-up look. They are expertly crafted to help your lashes look bold and beautiful with their fuller coats. If you wish to add a pop of dark color to your everyday eye look, go for the L’Oreal Paris Voluminous Original Mascara – Deep Burgundy. You can also try the Maybelline Great Lash Mascara – Royal Blue to sport a trendy party look, while the NYX Professional Makeup Color Mascara – Purple gives you a lengthening effect that helps you stand out of the crowd. Lightweight and ultra-conditioning, these mascaras offer exceptional results and are waterproof and completely flake-free. However, for people with sensitive eyes, you should ensure that the mascaras you have chosen do not affect the delicate area around your eyes. Instead, opt for dermatologist-tested or expert-recommended mascaras and patch test before application to avoid irritating your eyes.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
Srijita De, the author, is a makeup and fashion enthusiast who enjoys reviewing beauty products for her readers. She had read several customer reviews and researched the colored mascaras to narrow down a list of the best options available on the market. Her recommended products are lightweight, long-lasting, smudge-proof, and waterproof. These high-quality colored mascaras will help you create dramatic eyes in a matter of seconds.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are Colored Mascaras Good?
Absolutely! Colored Mascaras help enhance the color of your iris and make your lashes pop thus making your eyes look all the more stunning. So yes, they are definitely good.
Are Colored Mascaras Tacky?
No, if you choose the right color and formula! Colored mascaras are definitely gutsy but not tacky at all. On choosing the right pigment and formula, anyone can nail the perfect colored mascara look.
Which Is The Best Colored Mascara For Green Eyes?
NYX Professional Makeup Color Mascara (Purple), Clinique Chubby Lash Fattening Mascara (Portly Plum), and GL-Turelifes Handaiyan Mascara (Crimson) are some of the best-colored mascaras for green eyes.
How do you use colorful mascara?
Layer your colored mascara over a black one to add depth to your eyes. As colored mascaras are flattering, choose the right color that suits your skin tone.
Does colored mascara work on dark lashes?
If you have dark-toned eyelashes then it might be hard for your colored mascara to pop out. To make the colors look more prominent, coat your lashes with a white eyelash primer.
How do you get colored mascara to show up?
To show up colored mascara use a complimentary colored background. Try blue mascara on orange-tone eyeshadow, green mascara on pinkish red-toned eyeshadow and finally for a purple mascara, try a yellow-tone eye shadow.
How can I make my colored mascara brighter?
Use light colored eyeshadows to make the colored mascara look more brighter.
Can eyelashes be different colors?
Eyelashes are similar to scalp and body hair. The color of the eyelashes is also dependent on the body melanin-content.
Read full bio of Lorrie Pearson
Read full bio of Srijita De
Read full bio of Rajeshwari Das
Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury
Community Experiences
Join the conversation and become a part of our empowering community! Share your stories, experiences, and insights to connect with other beauty, lifestyle, and health enthusiasts.