13 Best Expert-Approved Drugstore Tubing Mascaras (2024)
Grab these smudge-proof drugstore tubing mascaras that give your eyes definition.
.
Read full bio of Marin McCarthy
Baishali is a beauty and lifestyle writer and holds a master's degree in English from Assam University. She specializes in makeup and fashion and is also a certified Style and Image Consultant. Prior to this, she was a part of a digital marketing company in Kolkata where she wrote stories on travel, beauty, and home décor.
Read full bio of Baishali Bhattacharya
Experience: 3 yearsKrati is an associate commerce editor, a certified skin care coach, and a beauty enthusiast. She has a master’s degree in advertising and publishing relations from DAVV University and three years of experience in writing and editing for different niches.
Read full bio of Krati Darak
Experience: 7 yearsMadhumati is an associate editor with seven years of professional experience. She has previously worked as an editor, proofreader, and a writer with various organizations, helping her navigate through the various facets of content creation and refinement with ease.
Read full bio of Madhumati Chowdhury
StyleCraze believes in credibility and giving our readers access to authentic and evidence-based content. Our stringent editorial guidelines allow us to only cite from reputed research institutions, academic journals, and medically established studies. If you discover any discrepancy in our content, you may contact us.
Image: shutterstock
If you are looking for a smudge-proof, long-lasting mascara that is simple to remove at the end of the day, you should grab the best drugstore tubing mascara as soon as you can. The benefits of the newest generation tubing mascaras are innumerable as they add length and volume by coating each lash with water-resistant polymer fibers. You can also remove them with a regular makeup remover or even warm water without rubbing your lashes too hard.
High-end drugstore cosmetics brands have a wide variety of tubing mascaras on offer. To make choosing the best one a little easier, I asked Marin McCarthy, a professional makeup artist, for advice and curated the list of 13 best tubing mascaras for you. I have also explained how to use and remove tubing mascaras. Keep scrolling!
In This Article
13 Best Drugstore Tubing Mascaras Of 2024 That You Need Right Now!
1. Best Smudge-Proof Formula: L’Oreal Paris Makeup Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara
Starting with highly rated tubing mascaras, Welcome to the next generation of L’Oreal Paris mascaras. The Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara provides a revolutionary dramatic lash extension effect. It nourishes the lashes and makes them look 80% longer. YouTuber Kristi Bergman, adds, “The lashes look very individually coated and nicely separated. I like this as a lower-lash mascara, I feel like it makes my lower lashes look so long. It’s pretty lengthening since it really does coat the very tips of the lashes.” The formula is suitable for those with sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. It comes with a primer to coat your lashes before applying the mascara. It makes the lashes look long, voluminous, and fluttery. The luxury mascara stays put for sixteen hours and is super-easy to take off with a cotton pad and warm water, or a regular makeup remover. It does not smudge, crumble, flake, or bleed. It is lightweight and gives your eyes definition as the best no-mess application tubing mascara. YouTuber Kristi Bergman says, “The wand is kind of small with a lot of brush-like bristles and I love like a smaller mascara wand to hopefully not have as much mascara end up all over my eyelid…I like this as a lower lash mascara I feel like it makes my lower lashes look so long…It’s not super volumizing but I do like how all the lashes are staying separated it’s pretty lengthening since it really does coat the very tips of the lashes (i).”
Pros
- Makes the lashes look 80% longer
- Nourishes the lashes
- Lasts up to sixteen hours
- Dual-ended
- Comes with a primer
- Smudge-proof
- Does not flake or crumble
- Easy to remove
- Lightweight
- Reasonably priced
Cons
- Contains parabens and sulfates
- May irritate sensitive eyes
2. Best Wax-Free Formula: Maybelline New York Snapscara
The Maybelline New York Snapscara is a new, wax-free formula from one of the most used and trusted drugstore brands. The mascara brush glides and coats each lash with polymer and color. It lengthens, curls, and adds volume to the lashes. YouTuber Elise Marie Beauty, adds, “The fan effect works so nice to get those outer lashes. The length is nice, the color is nice, very black in its tone.” The formula does not have dulling waxes and does not make the mascara look clumpy. It can be applied effortlessly. The mascara wand is long enough to provide good grip and control. The brush shape is curved to fit the contours of the eyes. The tapering tip allows access to the short and fine eyelashes in the corners of the eyes and the lower lashes. The mascara comes in various eye-catching colors like Deja Blue and Ultra Violet, along with the regular Pitch Black and Black Cherry.
Pros
- Wax-free formula.
- Brush glides and coats each lash with polymer and color.
- Can be applied effortlessly
- Lightweight
- Long wand provides good grip and control
- Curved brush fits the contours of the eyes
- Tapering tip coats short and fine eyelashes and lower eyelashes
- Available in various eye-catching colors
- Affordable
Cons
- Contains sulfates
Pro Tip
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
With 5,776 positive reviews on Amazon, this product has become a bestseller.
3. Best Long-Lasting Formula: Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara
If you want super-dynamic and long eyelashes, try the Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara. This lengthening tubing mascara has a 5mm long-fiber that makes your lashes look super-long, fluttery, and beautiful. YouTuber Mae Sitler, adds, “I’m pretty impressed, the curl is really good, it is super black and it almost looks like I’m wearing eyeliner. After eight hours nothing has really changed.” It separates the lashes without any clumps and leaves them with a glossy finish. The long-lasting formula of the tubing mascara contains Super Guard Polymer which is a durable ingredient. It is a sweat-resistant tubing mascara which is also resistant to tears, sweat, water, oils, and abrasions. It remains smudge-proof all day long.
This is the best mascara for curl as it is infused with curl-locking ingredients with Memory-Shape Polymers. They lift and curl the lashes in an instant, making them stay in place for many hours. The natural ingredients of the mascara – camellia oil, royal jelly extract, argan oil, and wild rose oil protect the sensitive lashes from damage and irritation.
Pros
- Has a 5mm long-fiber
- Separates the lashes
- Does not clump
- Leaves the lashes with a glossy finish
- Super Guard Polymer is resistant to tears, sweat, water, oils, and abrasions
- Protects sensitive lashes from damage and irritation
- Smudge-proof
- Formulated with Memory-Shape Polymer
- Wears long
Cons
- Not waterproof
- May take some time to remove
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
More than 5,480 rave reviews on Amazon prove why we are so in awe of this product.
| L'Oreal Paris Makeup Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara Best Smudge-Proof Formula | Maybelline New York Snapscara Best Wax-Free Formula | Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara Best Long-Lasting Formula | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color | Black | 300 WASHABLE PITCH BLACK | black. |
| Dimensions | 7.03 x 2.71 x 0.83 inches | 2.75 x 0.75 x 5.63 inches | - |
| Weight | 0.33 Ounces | 1.6 Ounces | - |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 12,612 | 5,776 | 5,480 |
| Price | $9.48 | $5.05 | $22.99 |
4. Best Affordable Option: Maybelline New York Illegal Length Fiber Extensions Mascara
The Maybelline New York Illegal Length Fiber Extensions Mascara adds drama to the eyes. It has a sealing formula that extends the length of each eyelash and seals the fiber securely. It does not flake, clump, or break. The fiber-fix brush reaches each lash from different angles for optimal fiber placement. This washable mascara is ophthalmologist-tested and contact lens-safe. Just a few strokes are enough to add definition and length to each eyelash and curl it up. A blogger mentions, “I really like this mascara! With just two coats, (which is all I have time for honestly) I get longer lashes! Since it isn’t marketed as a “volumizing” mascara, I didn’t expect much from it, but this does give me some volume surprisingly! I would definitely purchase this again (ii)!” The jojoba oil keeps the lashes nourished and hydrated. The fiber-fix brush coats the lashes from the root to the tip to reveal fluttery, voluminous lashes that are long and separated. This affordable tubing mascara can be removed easily with any oil-free makeup remover.
YouTuber SimpleCharmLiving, says, “It can clump a little bit as this feels like a drier formula, nothing comes off, so that’s both good and bad. Good because when you apply you don’t have to worry about getting it all over your eyes. I give this a thumbs up and I think I’ll continue buying this from the drugstore because it has done a really good job.”
Pros
- Does not flake, clump, or break
- Fiber-fix brush reaches each lash from different angles for optimal fiber placement
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Contact lens-
- Jojoba oil keeps the lashes nourished and hydrated
- Can be removed easily with any oil-free makeup remover
- Affordable
Cons
- Brush has short bristles
- The formula is a little drying.
- Contains PEG
"This mascara enhances my lashes and thickens their appearance. It holds up well without smearing on my lash lines. The formula never flakes, but comes off easily when I use micellar water. The best part is that it never leaves behind residues."
Pro TipWhy We Think It's Worth Buying
There are more than 2,469 Amazon reviews attesting to the quality of the product and endorsing its value.
5. Best Waterproof Formula: DHC Mascara Perfect Pro Double Protection
The DHC Mascara Perfect Pro Double Protection is long-wearing. It lasts all day and night, and does not break, flake, or irritate the eyes. Bene, a beauty and makeup blogger on Instagram, says, “I love it mostly because it’s safe for my sensitive eyes & it might be the only other mascara that doesn’t smudge much on my under eyes.” The brush coats each lash in an intense color with the polymer fibers. They make the eyelashes longer, thicker, and more lifted. The formula easily slides off with warm water without the need for any makeup remover. The ease of removal feature makes this mascara a good buy. It is waterproof and stays on for a long duration. The applicator brush is thin, which allows coating the top and bottom eyelashes with precision. YouTuber LittleLips adds, “I was also attracted to the fact that the wand is skinny, because I feel like that tends to give more definition.” The packaging design is sleek and looks classy.
Pros
- Long-wearing
- Lasts all day and night
- Does not break or flake
- Does not irritate the eyes
- Does not require a makeup remover
- Waterproof formula
- The applicator brush coats the top and bottom eyelashes with precision
- The packaging design is sleek and looks classy
- Reasonably priced
Cons
- May smudge under the eyes
- Formula dries up quickly
- Contains PEG
Pro Tip6. Best Clump-Free Formula: L’Oréal Paris Voluminous False Fiber Lashes Mascara
When it comes to original tubing mascaras, L’Oreal Paris is sweeping the market off with its brilliant products. The L’Oréal Paris Voluminous False Fiber Lashes Mascara creates a false eyelash effect as its sculpting formula makes the lashes look longer, thicker, fanned out, and curled. The mascara lifts the eyelashes and provides definition to the eyes. The lightweight and washable formula is clump-free, flake-free, and smudge-proof. It is an ophthalmologist-tested tubing mascara and contact lens-safe product, ideal for everyday wear. It is free of fragrance and other eye-irritating ingredients. The wand is angled so that all of the lashes can be coated evenly. The mascara adds an intense 3D impact and makes the lashes appear fuller, curled, and longer.
Pros
- Adds a false lash effect
- Lightweight and washable formula
- Clump-free
- Flake-free
- Smudge-proof
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Contact lens-safe
- Fragrance-free
- Free of other eye-irritating ingredients
- Angled wand ensures all lashes are coated evenly.
- Adds an intense 3D impact
- Reasonably priced
Cons
- Contains parabens
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
This product has received 769 reviews from customers on Amazon, indicating its popularity and reliability.
7. Best Volumizing Technology: Boots No7 Stay Perfect Mascara
The Boots No7 Stay Perfect Mascara has a new and unique tubular technology. It lengthens the lashes and offers perfection lasting up to 24 hours. It coats each eyelash individually with a special film, which creates tiny elastic tubes around the lashes. These fibers add length and volume to the lashes. This volumizing mascara also coats the lower lashes with precision. The lash wrap brush separates and coats every lash with a flexible and thicker formula from root to the tip. The mascara does not clump, break, or flake. It can easily be removed by washing with warm water.
Pros
- A unique, new tubular technology
- Offers lash protection for up to 24 hours
- Does not clump, break, or flake
- Can be easily removed by washing with warm water
- Does not irritate the eyes
- Does not pull out or break eyelashes
- Reasonably priced
Cons
None
8. Best Lightweight Formula: Covergirl Professional Remarkable Mascara
The Cover girl Professional Remarkable Mascara is long-lasting and smudge-proof. It is easy to remove with just water and soap. The unique formula makes the lashes look longer, thicker, and fanned out. The mascara does not smear. It keeps the eyelashes defined all day long. The twist-open packaging is lightweight. The wand is long and allows one to apply the mascara from a safe distance. The fibers in the brush coat the eyelashes from the root to the tip. The tapered tip provides easy access to the lower lashes and the fine and small lashes in the inner corners. The flake-free tubing mascara does not pull the eyelashes out. It is one of the best drugstore tubing mascaras available under $10.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Smudge-proof
- Easy to remove with just water and soap
- Does not smear
- Does not flake
- Does not crumble
- Llightweight packaging
- Longwand allows one to apply the mascara from a safe distance
- Tapered tip provides easy access to small lashes and lower lashes
- Affordable
Cons
- The formula dries quickly
9. Best Ophthalmologist-Tested: L’Oreal Paris Voluminous X Fiber Washable Mascara
If you have fine eyelashes and want to oomph them up for a lash extension-look, go for the L’Oreal Paris Voluminous X Fiber Washable Mascara. Its new and innovative formula adds seven times more volume to the lashes. It adds extreme volume and depth. This tubing mascara is easily washable and it imparts buildable volume to the lashes. It is fiber-infused, smudge-free, ophthalmologist-tested, and allergy-tested. Applying a coat of primer before applying the mascara helps prep the lashes for the fibers. The clean mascara does not clump, break, or pull the lashes out. It can be removed easily with warm water. The brushes are perfect for applying and coating the primer and the mascara from the root to the tip.
Pros
- Innovative formula adds 7x volume to the lashes
- Washable mascara
- Fiber-infused
- Smudge-free
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Allergy-tested
- Primer preps the lashes for fibers
- Does not clump, break, or pull the lashes out
- Reasonably priced
Cons
- Contains sulfates
"I love how voluminous and thicker my lashes look after just one coat of this mascara. The wand coats each of my lashes and gives them a voluminous look. The mascara never smudges and gives me panda eyes. I can easily remove it with some soapy water. The product never makes my lashes brittle."
10. Best Cruelty-Free Formula: Essence Volume Stylist Lash Extension with Fiber Mascara
The Essence Volume Stylist Lash Extension with Fiber Mascara is enriched with lengthening fibers. It provides eighteen hours of elegant, long, fluttery, and voluminous lashes. This non-irritaing tubing mascara flaunts an ergonomic design of the fiber-releasing brush that reaches even the smallest of lashes. It coats the lashes from the root to the tip, leaving you with gorgeous, fanned out, and long, voluminous eyelashes. The long-lasting formula does not crumble, flake, fade or weigh heavy on the lashes. It also does not irritate the eyes. The packaging is sturdy, and the wand has the perfect length to provide good grip and control. It is a vegan, cruelty-free mascara and adds a false lash-effect. It can be easily removed by any makeup remover.
Pros
- Adds a false lash-effect
- Cruelty-free
- Provides 18-hour wear
- Fiber-releasing brush reaches even the smallest of lashes
- Does not clump the lashes
- Does not irritate the eyes
- Packaging is sturdy
- Wand has the perfect length to provide good grip and control
- Affordable
- Budget-friendly
Cons
- Contains sulfates
11. Best Flake-Proof Formula: Revlon Mega Multiplier Mascara
The Revlon Mega Multiplier Mascara plumps and extends eyelashes in just one step. This drugstore tubing mascara is smudge-proof, water-resistant, flake-proof, and can be removed easily with warm water. It fans out and curls the lashes. The Mega Lash Brush deposits this unique formula from the root to the tip of the lashes. The formula stays locked in place all day by a special film that creates tiny elastic tubes around your lashes. The mascara is wax-free and does not make your lashes look dull or drooped. It is available in four shades. This easy-to-remove tubing mascara is affordable and comes in attractive packaging.
Pros
- Smudge-proof
- Water-resistant
- Flake-proof
- Can be removed easily with warm water
- The formula stays locked in place all day
- Does not make your lashes look dull or droop
- Available in four shades
- Affordable
Cons
- May not layer well
- Dries quickly
12. Best Fiber-Infused Formula: NYX Professional Makeup Boudoir Mascara Collection
The NYX Professional Makeup Boudoir Mascara Collection has a unique applicator brush. It lengthens, darkens, and adds volume to the eyelashes from the root to the tip and is the best mascara for natural lashes. The fiber-infused tubing formula does not clump or flake. This is one of the best mascara for volume addition and can be easily removed with warm water or any makeup remover. This drugstore tubing mascara helps create fanned-out lashes. It also lasts long and adds a lift to the eyes. The wand has the perfect length for good grip and control while applying the mascara. The brush is designed to coat the upper and lower lashes with precision. This clump-free tubing mascara is super affordable and reliable.
Pros
- Fiber-infused formula
- Does not clump or flake
- Can be easily removed with warm water or any makeup remover
- Lasts long
- Adds a lift to the eyes
- Super-affordable
Cons
- Dries out quickly
"This mascara lengthens and voluminizes my lashes. My eyes look big after I use this mascara. The wand features soft, flexible bristles that feel smooth against my lashes. The mascara does not clump my lashes or break them. It is also smudge-proof."
13. Best Stain-Resistant: Ellocy 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara
For that extra volume and length, try the Ellocy 4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara. It contains 4D silk fiber lashes and delicate ingredients that are super safe for the eyes. This hypoallergenic tubing mascara is ophthalmologist-tested and is safe to use. People wearing contact lenses can also apply this mascara. It has two sides – one side has the primer, and the other has the mascara. Apply the primer first to prep the lashes for the mascara. Next, apply the lash-extending mascara to achieve a dense and voluminous effect.
This lash-defining tubing mascara does not clump or flake and stays put the whole day. It is infused with natural beeswax. This drugstore tubing mascara is water-proof and stain-resistant. The smooth and creamy formula evenly spreads over all the lashes. It creates an attractive and flawless lashes with just one application. It is regarded as one of the best mascaras for waterproof application. It is also easy to remove with a makeup remover.
Pros
- Contains 4D silk fiber
- Delicate ingredients that are super safe for the eyes
- Ophthalmologist-tested
- Hypoallergenic
- Easy to remove with a makeup remover
- Dual-sided
- Comes with a primer
- Ergonomic design
- Smooth and creamy mascara formula spreads evenly
- Does not clump or flake
- Stays put the whole day
- Waterproof
- Stain-resistant
- Reasonably priced
Cons
- Maybe too stringy
These are the thirteen drugstore tubing mascaras that you can lay your hands on. If you are a new user, the following step-by-step guide on how to use one can help.
How To Use A Tubing Mascara
- Apply the mascara after finishing your eye-makeup.
- Twist open the mascara and take off the excess mascara on the edge of the tube.
- Look straight in the mirror and start coating the lashes from the root to the tip, using a “swipe-up” motion.
- Use the tapering tip to coat the inner, small eyelashes and the bottom eyelashes.
- If your tubing mascara comes with a primer, apply the primer first.
- Do the same on the other eye.
- Use a lash comb to give your lashes a final touch.
The following buying guide can help you make a better purchase decision.
Tips To Choose The Right Drugstore Tubing Mascara
To choose the right drugstore tubing mascara, here’s what you need to look for:
- Go for a mascara that is allergy-tested.
- Pick a drugstore mascara that says “lengthening and volumizing” on the package.
- Check for words like “ fiber” or “polymer”.
- Check the ingredients list for any harmful chemicals.
- Check how long the mascara stays.
- Check if the mascara causes clumping or flaking.
- Check the wand. It should not be too short or too long.
- Check the brush. It should be designed to coat both the long and short lashes.
Infographic: How To Pick The Best Drugstore Tubing Mascara
Volumize and lengthen your lashes with the right drugstore tubing mascaras! Some natural-looking tubing mascaras come with delicate formulas that keep your eyes well-nourished and free from damage. However, you must know how to go for the right option to achieve denser lashes.
Take a look at the below infographic that explains the pointers you must remember before picking a suitable drugstore tubing mascara to enhance your eye makeup! Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team
The Bottom Line
If you are a fan of waterproof makeup products, these drugstore tubing mascaras are just for you! Unlike regular mascaras, these smudge-proof tubing mascaras are highly pigmented and transfer-resistant. They have creamy consistencies and contain natural oils that smoothly glide on the eyelids and moisturize them. They add volume and lengthen the lashes. The L’Oreal Paris Makeup Double Extend Beauty Tubes Mascara nourishes the lashes while the Heroine Make Long and Curl Mascara gives a glossy finish, and the Maybelline New York Snapscara offers a clump-free volume. These drugstore tubing mascara brands offer products that are gluten-free, lightweight, have water-based formulas, and are easy to remove. However, some products may irritate your sensitive skin. So check closely before investing in your favorite tubing mascara for your makeup needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a tubing mascara bad for your lashes?
No, a lightweight tubing mascara adds length and volume to your lashes for a false lash or a lash extension look. It also can be removed easily without irritating the eyes or causing lash breakage. Hence, it is not bad for your lashes.
Do tubing mascaras hold a curl?
Yes, tubing mascaras hold curls for a long time. They lift the eyes and make them appear bigger.
Can you use tubing mascara over regular mascara?
Yes, tubing mascaras help lengthen your lashes. You can layer them with regular mascaras or use them separately to add some definition to your lashes.You can also use a separating tubing mascara for a more defined look.
How do you know if a mascara is a tubing mascara?
You can easily know whether a mascara is a tubing mascara through its ingredients list. If there are fibers and polymers on the list of ingredients, then that mascara is a tubing one.
How long should a tube of mascara last?
A tube of mascara should last at least three to four months if you put it on regularly.
Why does my mascara dry out so fast?
There are several reasons why mascaras can dry out too fast. If you move the wand in quick succession, also known as ‘pumping’, then mascaras can dry out. They can also dry out due to less frequent use. However, they can be revived with eye drops or mixing liquid.
How many times a week should I wear mascara?
You can wear your mascara regularly but make sure to take a week’s break in the middle to let your lashes breathe. Wearing one coat of mascara daily would not hurt your lashes, but if you are someone who puts on double or triple coats, it is recommended to wash them off as soon as you get home. It is best to opt for an all-day wear tubing mascara for the best results.
How long is a mascara tube good for once opened?
Mascaras have a shelf of six to twelve months once opened. It is not recommended to use a mascara tube for more than that period of time. Some mascaras can accumulate bacteria and other harmful impurities if used more than the specified time.
How do you know when your mascara has run out?
You can know if your mascara has run out when it no longer drags out a decent amount of product while pumping. Mascaras that are almost running out provide no lash definition or color payoff.
How to remove tubing mascara?
The best part is tubing mascaras does not need any specific makeup remover. Just simply wet a cotton pad with warm water and hold it against your lashes to gently wipe off for a clear look.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
The author, Baishali Bhattacharya, is certified in makeup artistry and is dedicated to reviewing premier makeup products for her readers. She feels that you can look your absolute best with a tubing mascara that is affordable and easily available. So, she read through several product reviews, checked brand websites, and conducted research and collated this list of the best drugstore tubing mascaras. These mascaras are waterproof, long-lasting, and add length and volume to your eyelashes.
References
Articles on StyleCraze are backed by verified information from peer-reviewed and academic research papers, reputed organizations, research institutions, and medical associations to ensure accuracy and relevance. Read our editorial policy to learn more.
(i). Kristi Bergman
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TBbVfczCAxc&t=4s
(ii). Simple Charm Beauty
http://simplecharmbeauty.blogspot.com/search?q=Maybelline+Illegal+Length+Fiber+Extensions+
Read full bio of Baishali Bhattacharya
Read full bio of Krati Darak
Read full bio of Madhumati Chowdhury
Community Experiences
Join the conversation and become a part of our empowering community! Share your stories, experiences, and insights to connect with other beauty, lifestyle, and health enthusiasts.