14 Best Eye Pencil Sharpeners For Sharp Tips, Expert’s Picks
Sharpen the edges of your eyeliners for precise application with these sharpeners.
Mary Ajaka is a celebrity makeup artist with 15 years of experience in TV/media, editorial, and bridal makeup. She has a keen eye for detail and understands that each face is unique, which is why she uses different makeup techniques tailored to the individual.
Read full bio of Mary Ajaka
Experience: 3 yearsSrijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant.
Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury
Experience: 2 yearsSrijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world.
Read full bio of Srijita De
Experience: 3 yearsKrati is an associate commerce editor, a certified skin care coach, and a beauty enthusiast. She has a master’s degree in advertising and publishing relations from DAVV University and three years of experience in writing and editing for different niches.
Read full bio of Krati Darak
Image: Shutterstock
Eyeliners and eye pencils are quite common in our daily makeup routines and in the world of makeup artistry, but the struggle begins when they start going blunt after regular use. This is where the best eye pencil sharpener can help. Using eye pencil sharpeners helps to keep your pencil liners sharp so that you get the perfect winged eyeliner look with every use. Moreover, a sharpened eyeliner produces exceptional results as it helps avoid smudging and ensures a smooth and precise application.
Since it is a common problem that most of us face, we have compiled this list of the 14 best eye pencil sharpeners that can make your eye pencils and eyeliners pointy to ensure precise application. We have a mix of products that are perfect for both thin and thick eye pencils, and the cherry on top is that these versatile tools are affordable. Scroll down and take your pick.
In This Article
14 Incredible Eye Pencil Sharpeners For Sharp & Pointed Tips – 2024
1. Best User-Friendly Product:L’Oreal Paris Dual Sharpener
For your eyebrow pencils that lose their shape or for your eyeliner pencils that lose their sharp tip, the L’Oreal Paris Dual-hole Sharpener is best suited for slim and jumbo pencils. It perfectly sharpens your pencils and traditional liners to restore their shape so you can get a flawless makeup application. According to some online reviews, this eyeliner pencil sharpener takes about 3 turns to get the chiseled tip that will help you apply your makeup with precision.
Pros
- Comes with a tight-fitting lid to contain the mess
- Duo sharpener with german blades
- Can be used for a lip liner
- Easy-to-use
Cons
- The mess might build up under the blade
"This eye pencil sharpener has a dual-size design. It gives precise points without unnecessary waste or breakage. It has a sturdy build and does not break during accidental drops. The transparent case does not clog and can be easily cleared when required."
Quick Tip2. Best Mess-Free Use:Tweezerman Deluxe Cosmetic Sharpener
This pencil sharpener uses a patented double blade system that sharpens your pencils to a slightly rounded tip and prevents breakage. This cosmetic pencil sharpener is suitable for traditional liners and pencils that are both thick and thin, including jumbo pencils and cosmetic crayons. Reviewers have noted that the Tweezerman Deluxe Cosmetic Sharpener is convenient and comes with a transparent lid to hold the shavings.
Pros
- Creates rounded tips that are gentle on the skin
- Suitable for chubby sticks
- Removable, adjustable plug
- Cover to keep it mess-free
Cons
- Not all pencils may fit
"This eyeliner sharpener is perfect. It creates a smooth and splinter-free point without excess waste or mess. Opening its lid can be a bit tricky at first but it is easy to use. It works well for regular-size pencils."
3. Best For Precise Sharpening:Revlon Universal Points Sharpener
A must-have beauty tool in your collection, the Revlon Universal Points Sharpener helps you get precise point application and is perfect for sharpening various types of pencils, including twist-up pencils. This black-colored eyebrow pencil sharpener from the celebrity-endorsed brand can be used for 3 different sizes, starting from slim to jumbo. Just remove the extra adaptor ring to sharpen even your most wide crayon pencil and keep it in perfect shape. The Revlon Universal Points Sharpener ensures that you achieve a fine point for your pencils, allowing for precise and accurate application.
Pros
- Quick and easy sharpening
- Sharpens plastic pencils with ease
- Lift the top to empty the shavings.
- Clean the blades easily with the safety pick.
Cons
- Might sharpen unevenly
"This sharpener sharpens smoothly without breakage. It is compact and travel-friendly and does not slip out of my hands. I make sure that its scrap compartment does not overfill. I have noticed that it becomes a bit fussy with very short or dull pencils, but overall, it gives a nice point to liners and doesn't waste product."
Pro Tip
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
With over 19,075 reviews, this product has become a fan favorite among users.
| L’Oreal Paris Dual Sharpener Best User-Friendly Product | Tweezerman Deluxe Cosmetic Sharpener Best Mess-Free Use | Revlon Universal Points Sharpener Best User-Friendly Product | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color | Dual Sharpener W/Clr Cvr | Assorted | - |
| Dimensions | 1.12 x 2.76 x 3.54 inches | 2.99 x 0.47 x 6.31 inches | 1.94 x 0.56 x 5.75 inches |
| Weight | 0.56 Ounces | 0.64 Ounces | 0.48 Ounces |
| Material | - | - | Wood, PlasticColor |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 1,247 | 1,717 | 19,075 |
| Price | $12.0 | $13.49 | $2.79 |
4. Best Durability:TIGI Cosmetics Metal Sharpener
Engineered in Germany, the TIGI Cosmetics Metal Sharpener is an amazing addition to your cosmetic collection. It is made with durable metal that is easy to carry around with you when you’re traveling. Due to its strong metal base, this lip pencil sharpener can be used on hard plastic pencils without having to worry about breaking them. Its high-quality construction ensures smudge-proof sharpening, providing you with clean and precise lines every time.
Pros
- Suitable for 2 sizes
- Works for slim and thick pencils
- The blades can be changed
- The metal base makes is highly durable
Cons
- Might be too loose for some pencils
5. Best For Ultra-Soft Pencils:Plum Flip Tip Sharpener
If you’re looking for a mess-free and precise sharpener, the Plum Flip Tip Sharpener is your best choice. This German-made precision sharpener reduces tip breakage and wastage of your precious eye and lip pencils. You can choose between rounded or sharp tips by using the in-built tip selector. It works perfectly even on hard pencils and ultra-soft formulas. Many reviews indicate that it also comes with a blade-cleaning stick for hassle-free maintenance.
Pros
- 100% mess-free
- Precision sharpener
- Reduces tip breakage
- In-built tip selector
Cons
- Not suitable for lip crayons
Quick Tip6. Best Premium-Quality Steel:NYX Professional Makeup Sharpener
If you’re looking for a compact, breezy yet effective sharpener, the NYX Professional Makeup Sharpener is your pick. It comes with a 2-in-1 sharpener hole that lets you keep your slim and jumbo pencils ready to use at all times. Its smooth and effortless motion gives you a precise application when you use this makeup pencil sharpener. You do not have to worry about smudged makeup anymore.
Pros
- Designed for durability and travel
- Compact 2-in-1 design
- Made with high-quality steel
- Comes with a case to prevent mess
- Blades can be removed and replaced
Cons
- Pencils might not fit perfectly
"This sharpener is quite handy for my everyday makeup kit. It creates sharp points on various pencils, particularly the ones with plastic bodies. The shavings get collected in the collection without any hassle."
7. Best Dual Blade Option:Nars Pencil Sharpener
What’s unique about this dark black wonder box is that it is designed to essentially sharpen pencils of every size. The Nars Pencil Sharpener has a customized dual blade and also includes a blade cleaner and a cover that helps store the shavings before clearing out the cover completely. This super jumbo pencil sharpener sharpens pencils smoothly and gives it a clean finish. This enhanced beauty tool is versatile enough to be used with large pencils as well.
Pros
- Works in just 3 sharp twists
- Blade evenly sharpens out the pencil
- Does not mess up lipstick or lip liner
Cons
- The cover might fall off
"This Nars sharpener cleanly sharpens various types of pencils without breakage or mess. It is easy to use and clean and does not create any mess. It is durable and gives me pointed sharpened tips without any issues."
8. Best In Budget:Elf Cosmetics Dual Pencil Sharpener
The easy-to-carry Elf Dual Pencil Sharpener is your essential tool to keep your makeup pencils sharpened. It has two different pencil holes, which helps you sharpen eye pencils of different sizes. The top cover encases all the shavings, which can be discarded later. These enhanced features make the dual pencil sharpener a must-have piece for your travel makeup kit, whether you are a professional makeup artist or an enthusiast. The sharpener is easy to clean and helps you draw precise lines during your eye makeup sessions.
Pros
- Professional-quality material
- Easy to carry
- Easy to clean
- Vegan
- Cruelty-free
Cons
- The clear lid may become loose
"This sharpener stands out for its durability and effectiveness. I can say that it is great with thicker pencils. The dual-hole design accommodates various pencil sizes as well. It comes with a cleaning tool that keeps the sharpener clear of shavings."
9. Best For Travel:ULTA Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener
Why worry about blunt pencil tips when you have ULTA Cosmetics Pencil Sharpener? This makeup pencil sharpener is double-bladed that gives your makeup pencils a sharp desired tip instantly for you to draw precise lines without much effort. It sharpens small and large tips effectively, giving it a rounded over-tip. Reviewers have noticed that it also has a storage box that keeps all sharpenings, preventing them from spilling into your purse.
Pros
- Double bladed sharpener
- Sharpens small and large tips
- Fits all sizes of cosmetic pencils
- Not tested on animals
Cons
- None
"This sharpener is great for different pencils. It works especially well on challenging plastic-bodied ones. The design offers a no-mess experience. It sharps well and its built-in top catches shavings without any hassle."
10. Best For Round Tips:Glo Skin Beauty Pencil Sharpener
Worried that your sharpener might waste a lot of your makeup pencil? With the Glo Skin Beauty Pencil Sharpener, you don’t have to worry about that ever again. Its unique blade sculpts your makeup pencil with minimal wastage. They are specially designed with two German-engineered blades that sharpen pencils according to your needs. Get round or sharp points to apply makeup with precision.
Pros
- Sharpens pencils with minimal wastage
- Long-lasting
- Includes a cleaning tool
Cons
- Might be too small
11. Best For Oversized Pencils:Trish McEvoy Dual Pencil Sharpener
The Trish McEvoy Dual Pencil Sharpener comes with German blades that offer fine sharpening, and the fully openable cover makes it easy to clean. You can sharpen every traditional and oversized pencil without breaking them. The cover snaps in to prevent messy makeup sharpening sessions.
Pros
- Durable blades
- User-friendly features
- Easy to clean
- Suitable to sharpen big pencils
Cons
- None
"This sharpener precisely sharpens my eye pencils without wasting much product. It is easy to clean and comes with a removal casing to avoid mess. It is also very easy to store."
12. Best Metal Blades:Prestige Cosmetics Duo Sharpener
The Prestige Cosmetics Duo Sharpener works well for round and sharp tips, it is made with stainless steel and gives your makeup pencils the edge they need. The unique feature of this metal sharpener is that it has a sharp blade to carve out your makeup as you need. You do not have to worry about a dull, smudged tip ever again if you buy this makeup sharpener.
Pros
- Long-lasting
- Easy-to-clean
- Sharp metal blades
Cons
- Does not work with retractable pencils
"This metal double-sided sharpener is my favorite. It handles even the gummier gel eyeliners with precision and minimal waste. I regularly clean it to maintain its efficiency. It is a functional find for me as I am tired of replacing eyeliners more than necessary!"
13. Best Customizable Settings:Kokie Makeup Pencil Sharpener
The Kokie Makeup Pencil Sharpener is your go-to product if you have always wanted a sharpener with adjustable settings. It comes equipped with German-precision fine blades, and the removable top and bottom make it easy to clean. The extra cleaning stick accessory is a savior for removing any stuck pieces.
Pros
- Durable design
- Secure lid
- Dual-blade feature
- Easy to clean
- Includes a blade-cleaning tool
Cons
- None
"This sharpener tackles both standard and jumbo-sized pencils. It sharpens my various lip and eye pencils without breaking the tips. It is easy to use and comes with a sturdy design. It is great for daily use."
14. Best Carbon Steel Blades:Julep Cosmetic Eyeliner Makeup Pencil Sharpener
With its unique design and convenience, the Julep Cosmetic Eyeliner Makeup Pencil Sharpener is made as a travel-friendly tool to help keep your makeup in shape even when you’re on the move. It is designed in a conical shape and contains a cap that stores the shavings. Use this makeup pencil sharpener for a clean, precise, and even application.
Pros
- Sharpens pencil to a pointed tip
- Mess-free conical tip
- Includes a pick for easy cleaning
- Made with carbon steel blades
Cons
- Blade gets blunt soon
"This Julep makeup pencil sharpener gives a smooth and perfect point. The shavings stay put in the shaving collector and do not make a mess. I insert the pencils and twist them gently to sharpen."
A good eye pencil sharpener is exactly what you might need to achieve those Insta-ready eye designs and elevate your statement-making looks. But, while we spend so much time picking the right eyeliner pencil, we often miss out on paying attention to this small and reliable tool. Given below are some points to keep in mind when buying an eye pencil sharpener for the best results.
How To Select the Best Eye Pencil Sharpener
- Blade Quality
The blade is the most important part you need to consider in a cosmetic sharpener. Look out for sharpeners that have quality material blades of German silver or carbon steel. Ensure that the blade is rust-resistant and has been rigorously tested.
- Design
Invest in a cosmetic sharpener that is sturdy and has a durable structure. Look for sharpeners that hold the blade and the cosmetic pencil in place giving you a consistent sharpness every time. Avoid designs that cause build-ups to collect on the blade.
- Cover
Ideally a cosmetic pencil sharpener should come with a cover or a cap to collect the shavings so that it does not create a mess every time you sharpen a pencil. It also keeps the balde protected.
- Additional Benefits
Choose eye pencil sharpeners that can be used on various products of different sizes and different formulas, from a lipstick to an eyebrow pencil. Choose sharpeners that come with different blade sizes and sharpening compartments in one body.
- Travel-Friendly
A good eye pencil sharpener should be compact and easy to store and carry around. It should be easy to carry in your small makeup pouches.
Now that you have gone through the list of the best eye pencil sharpeners, let’s look at a few tips on how to use one the right way.
How To Make The Best Use Of A Makeup Pencil Sharpener – Safety Tips And Advice
When Is It Time To Sharpen Your Pencil?
When you’re using your makeup pencil, it becomes vital to maintain a certain shape depending on how you want it to glide onto your face. A sharp-pointed tip will give you thin and sleek makeup while a rounded tip will give you thick makeup. Therefore, ensure that your makeup pencil is always in its best shape so you can get the perfect makeup finish.
How To Clean Your Eye Pencil Sharpener?
Your makeup pencil sharpener has to be cleaned from time to time to remove the makeup build on the blades. Some sharpeners come with a cleaning stick that lets you remove the guck from the blades. However, apart from this, you can use a cotton swab dipped in makeup remover or rubbing alcohol and clean out the blades of the sharpener.
How To Sharpen A Pencil Without A Sharpener?
It is recommended that you use an expertly crafted makeup pencil sharpener to maintain your makeup pencils. However, as an alternative, you can use a nail file to smoothen out the wood of the pencil. You can also use a scissor to sharpen your makeup pencils. But this might also result in some wastage of makeup.
Infographic: Cleaning Tips For Eye Pencil Sharpeners
Eye pencil sharpeners are a staple in many makeup kits, but they can be difficult to keep clean. Over time, makeup buildup can clog the sharpener and lead to breaks and waste. It can also make your eyeliner look less precise. Check out the infographic below for tips to keep them clean and effective.
Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team
The Bottom Line
Eyeliners are a common part of the daily makeup routine. And if you use pencil eyeliners for better control, you are well aware of the issue that they become blunt with regular usage. To resharpen them, you need eye pencil sharpeners that can do the job with minimal wastage and give you a perfectly smooth wing finish. The best ones come with a lid. Sharp tips help you with precise, flawless application. The sharpeners are available in different sizes and thicknesses. They are mess-free, long-lasting, and easy to clean. You can check out the L’Oreal Paris Dual Sharpener, which is ideal for big pencils, and the Tweezerman Deluxe Cosmetic Sharpener to prevent tip breakage. Another product to trust is the Revlon Universal Points Sharpener, which can be used for different pencil sizes. However, some sharpeners may not be compatible with every eyeliner. So, read the reviews before investing in your favorite eye pencil sharpener from our list.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I sharpen my eyeliner with a regular pencil sharpener?
Most eyeliners do not fit a regular pencil sharpener. We recommend that you do not avoid breakage or wastage of your makeup pencil.
Can I sharpen plastic and wooden eyeliner pencils?
Some sharpeners are suitable for plastic and wooden pencils while others are not. Therefore, make sure you know what you’re buying before choosing your makeup pencil sharpener.
Can I sharpen a soft makeup pencil?
Some sharpeners are designed to evenly shape your soft pencil makeup to give you the desired shape. However, not all sharpeners are suitable for the same.
How to sharpen soft eyeliners?
• Keep the soft eyeliner in a refrigerator for a couple of minutes.
• Take the eyeliner out and use a sharpener designed especially for soft eyeliner.
• Gently insert the pencil into the sharpener.
• Turn the pencil inside the sharpener slowly a few times.
• Pull out the liner carefully.
Why does eyeliner keep breaking?
Eyeliners are usually soft, so sharpening the tip continuously weakens the lead and breaks it. Also, sharpening a soft liner with a regular sharpener can break it.
How to clean an eye pencil sharpener?
• Remove the shavings and any excess lead from the sharpener.
• Dip a cotton swab in a makeup remover.
• Rub the cotton swab on the blades of the sharpeners. Also, clean the residue from the corners.
• Now, rub the outer part of the sharpener with the cotton swab.
• Spray some rubbing alcohol on the sharpener.
• Wipe it with a clean tissue and let the sharpener dry completely.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
The author of this article, Chaitra Krishnan, has a keen interest in makeup, and she takes it upon herself to try out different makeup products to help her readers pick the right fit. To this end, she has tried out many eye pencil sharpeners and also read online product reviews to compile an effective list of the best ones. The products listed below can cater to the requirements of different eye pencils to give you the desired look, and they are super affordable too.
Read full bio of Mary Ajaka
Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury
Read full bio of Srijita De
Read full bio of Krati Darak
Community Experiences
Join the conversation and become a part of our empowering community! Share your stories, experiences, and insights to connect with other beauty, lifestyle, and health enthusiasts.