15 Best Hair Dyes For Natural Hair – A Trichologist’s Top Picks Of 2024

Are you looking for the best salon-quality hair dye for natural hair to give yourself that awesome makeover? Then look no further. Today, brands have come up with clean hair dye products made from plant-based ingredients that make their use safe. Ghanima A, a cosmetologist and hair expert, says, “At-home hair coloring kits are affordable. You can get a kit that has everything you need for coloring your hair at home for as low as $20. Salon coloring can easily cost ten times as much. In addition, there is a wide variety of color choices, and, if needed, tools that come with the kit will help you color your hair without damaging your hair or scalp.” Sold at affordable prices, you can save yourself that expensive trip to the salon. Whether you’re feeling experimental or just want to look plain excellent, natural dyes are your go-to choice. We have compiled a list of the top 15 natural dyes you can try quickly at home. All these dyes are selected after careful consideration of their reviews on various forums and have an intense color payoff. Scroll down for more information.

15 Best Hair Dyes For Natural Hair – Our Top Picks To Try In 2024

1. Best Non-Drip Formula: Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Color Nourishing Color Creme

4.4

Image: Garnier

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.97

What’s unique about the Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Color Nourishing Color Creme is that it not only adds rich color to your hair but also offers a boost of hydration. The formula has some of the best nourishing ingredients, like a blend of triple fruit oils (avocado, olive, and shea). The non-drip creme spreads quickly on application and has a pleasant fragrance. The after-color moisture-locking conditioner keeps your hair silky and nourished. Available in varied color options, this ultra-reflective formula transforms even the darkest of hair colors to your desired hair color. Check out this video to explore a tester’s experience of using the product, to learn more about it.

Pro Tip

Apply this dye on dry, unwashed hair, leave it on for 25 minutes for better color development, and rinse. Then apply the Garnier Nourishing Conditioner for optimum hydration.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

The extensive 12,452 rave reviews on Amazon prove why we are vouching for this product.

2. Best For Adding Shine: L’Oreal Paris Superior Preference Fade-Defying Color + Shine System

4.5

Image: L’oreal Paris Superior Preference Fade-defying Color + Shine System

BUY ON AMAZON | $9.97

The L’Oreal Paris Superior Preference Fade-Defying Color + Shine System is a preferred at-home hair coloring kit that delivers super shiny and luxurious hair color. This long-lasting gel hair dye gives you shiny strands from root to tip, irrespective of your natural hair color. The package includes Care Supreme Conditioner with Shine Serum that maintains color vibrancy and provides silky and shiny hair. The professional-grade product offers a wide spectrum of shades, including various hues of blondes, browns, and reds making it one of the best hair dyes for natural hair. If you need more convincing, feel free to take a look at this YouTuber’s video that details a reviewer’s experience of using the product.

3. Best Ammonia-Free: Bigen Permanent Powder Hair Color

4.1

Image: Bigen Usa

BUY ON AMAZON | $51.75

The Bigen Permanent Powder Hair Color is excellent for those who want to enhance their natural hair tone. The powder formula is easy to mix with water and apply and it ensures maximum gray hair coverage. The ammonia-free formula is very gentle on the scalp and gives a natural-looking shine to your hair. This long-lasting formula does not lighten your hair so you can apply it without any worry. To know more about this dye, check this honest review on YouTube.

	Garnier Nutrisse Ultra Color Nourishing Color Creme Best Non-Drip Formula	L'Oreal Paris Superior Preference Fade-Defying Color + Shine System Best For Adding Shine	Bigen Permanent Powder Hair Color Best Ammonia-Free
	Buy Now	Buy Now	Buy Now
Color	BR3 Intense Burgundy (Lotus Berry)	9 Natural Blonde	Copper
Dimensions	2.2 x 3.25 x 6.25 inches	6.3 x 3.55 x 2.25 inches	-
Weight	7.83 Ounces	0.35 Ounces	-
Number of Items	-	-	12
Rating
Reviews	12,452	18,290	-
Price	$7.97	$9.97	$51.75

4. Best Mess-Free Application:John Frieda Precision Foam Color

4.4

Image: John Frieda

BUY ON AMAZON | $11.92

Getting flawless, salon-perfect coverage and hair color are now easier than ever with the John Frieda Precision Foam Color. It has a thick, saturating, and foaming formula that deposits the color for intense saturation and helps lock moisture.  This non-drip, moisturizing hair color spreads quickly for complete coverage without patchiness, making it ideal for dry hair. It is fade-resistant and offers 100% gray coverage. The after-color conditioner seals your hair color and provides long-lasting tonal richness.

Caution

This hair dye contains certain chemicals that may cause eye irritation and allergies. So, avoid using it for dyeing your lashes or eyebrows.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 11,392 rave reviews on Amazon prove why we are so in awe of this product.

5. Best Long-Lasting Results:Manic Panic Ultra Violet Hair Color Amplified

4.1

Image: Manic Panic

BUY ON AMAZON | $15.99

The Manic Panic Ultra Violet Hair Color Amplified is a fantastic, blue-toned, violet hair dye that offers you the perfect hue and lasts for 4-6 weeks, typically longer than traditional hair dyes. You can combine any formula to create custom shades, and the best part is, you don’t even require a developer. It has 30% more pigment than other commercial hair dyes and is long-lasting. You need one jar or bottle for short hair, two bottles for medium-length hair, and 2-3 bottles for thick hair. For long hair, you may need three or more jars. The product is available in more than 23 shades. It is recommended to perform a strand test before coloring the hair with it to check for sensitivities!

Pro Tip

Apply the hair color, then warm your hair for five to ten minutes with a hair dryer. This will open up your hair cuticles and intensify the color. Allow your hair to cool down naturally before rinsing it out with cold water

6. Best Affordable:Clairol Natural Instincts

4.4

Image: Clairol

BUY ON AMAZON | $20.97

If you are looking for one of the best hair dyes for natural hair available at drugstore then you can try Clairol. The Clairol Natural Instincts hair color is formulated with 80% natural ingredients specially developed for relaxed and natural hair. It enhances the natural hair color and makes it appear radiant, healthy-looking, and shiny. The product is enriched with coconut and aloe vera, and the no-drip creme formula feels like a conditioner on application. The color stays put for up to 28 washes. The product is available in 38 natural shades of blonde, brown, black, and red tones.

7. Best Dermatologist-Tested:Revlon Total Color

4.3

Image: Revlon

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.68

The Revlon Total Color has a nourishing formula that offers 100% gray hair coverage. It adds vibrant color that lasts for up to 6 weeks. The formula contains hemp seed oil and other shade-specific botanical extracts like sesame oil for brunettes, black tea extract for dark hair, cranberry for red shades, and chamomile for blondes. The non-toxic product has a non-drip, cream formula and is available in 16 shades.

8. Best Gray Coverage:Schwarzkopf Simply Color Permanent Color

4.2

Now 23% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $9.19

This permanent hair color by Schwarzkopf has a nourishing formula that offers up to 100% gray coverage. It is enriched with botanical oat milk, soy protein, and argan oil and provides vibrant color from root to tip. The formula is dermatologist-tested and maintains the health of your hair and scalp. The dye offers proven efficacy in maintaining vibrancy for up to 6 weeks. If your hair is longer than shoulder length, use two Simply Color hair dye boxes for the best results.

9. Best Deep Conditioning:dpHUE Gloss+ Semi-Permanent Hair Color

3.8

Now 10% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $37.5

The dpHUE Gloss+ Semi-Permanent Hair Color adds shine and softness to your hair on application. You can mix it with other pigmented shades to customize and create your favorite color. This semi-permanent hair color has a deep conditioning base and rich pigments that stain the outside of your hair. In addition, it is rich in hydrating ingredients that leave the hair soft and shiny. This hydrating hair dye is gentle on natural hair and works on both natural and color-treated hair, providing customizable shades for a personalized look.

10. Best Fade-Resistant:Just 5 Permanent Hair Color

4.5

Image: Just 5 Permanent Hair Color

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.69

As the name suggests, Just 5 Permanent Hair Color takes just 5 minutes to color your hair and lasts for up to 6 weeks. Its ammonia-free formula efficiently covers all the gray hair, and the color blends effortlessly. The conditioning base of the product protects and revitalizes your hair, makes it shiny, and boosts its body and manageability. The formula is gentle, and the color won’t fade away even if you shampoo frequently.

11. Best Shade Range: ONC NaturalColors

3.9

Image: Onc Naturalcolors

BUY ON AMAZON | $24.95

The ONC NaturalColors permanent hair dye is formulated with naturally derived ingredients like argan oil, aloe vera, orange extracts, chamomile, coconut oil, and vitamins that make your hair shiny, silky, and soft. The hair color covers stubborn gray strands and gives you the perfect, desirable hair color with no damage. It is available in more than 30 shades.

12. Best Plant-Based Formula:naturcolor Haircolor With Plant Extracts

4.2

Image: Natur Color

BUY ON AMAZON | $16.45

The naturcolor Haircolor With Plant Extracts is a high-quality dye that offers long-lasting, vibrant color without damaging your hair. It is made of natural plant-based ingredients and the finest Italian pigments that strengthen and nourish your hair strands. It is free of any harmful chemicals making it safe and gentle on the scalp and hair. It’s an easy-to-use gel formula that takes less than an hour for the complete application. This hair dye is also safe to use on color-treated or permed hair. It is available in 31 beautiful shades ranging from deep browns to intense reds.

13. Best Hydrating:Arctic Fox Semi-Permanent Hair Dye

4.5

Image: Arctic Fox

BUY ON AMAZON | $12.99

Looking for a vibrant hue without bleach? Try out the Arctic Fox Semi-Permanent Hair Dye. Unlike other chemical-based hair colors, this hair dye is chemical-free, formulated with vegan ingredients. The color shows up well in brassy tones and gives dark, dimensional tints to darker hair. The brand recommends doing a strand test before coloring.

14. Best For Relaxed Hair:Soft Sheen-Carson Dark and Lovely Fade Resist

4.3

Image: Soft Sheen

BUY ON AMAZON | $4.99

The Soft Sheen-Carson Dark and Lovely Fade Resist is an intensely pigmented hair color. It is infused with shea, avocado, and olive oil that nourish your relaxed hair and protect it against free radical damage. This non-drip, hair color kit provides ultimate gray coverage, prevents hair breakage for colored hair, and lasts up to 8 weeks. It does not dry out your hair post-coloring, instead, it leaves your hair softer and silkier. This dye is also enriched with argan oil and vitamin E that coats each strand with moisture. This dye is available in a variety of unique shades.

15. Best For Sensitive Skin:Herbatint – 1N Black

4.2

Now 37% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $25.32

The Herbatint in 1N Black is enriched with eight certified herbal extracts. It improves hair health by offering enhanced color and better shine. The formula of this hair color features nourishing ingredients like vitamins A, C, and E, aloe vera, enzymes, polysaccharides, and salt minerals that soothe the scalp. It is clinically tested to be safe for sensitive skin. It is safe to use and provides long-lasting color.

Note: Ghanima A suggests, “Always read the cautions of a box hair dye carefully before you leave the store. The instructions will let you know what color your hair will become with the dye, based on your hair’s color before you dye. It will also let you know if you can re-dye your hair with the product and how long you should wait to dye it after any other chemical treatment. Then, go through the instructions carefully when you get home. Try to follow the instructions as carefully as possible. If anything is unclear, try to find a video by the company that explains the process.”

So, this was the list of best hair dyes for natural hair. Not all hues may complement your natural hair color or your skin tone. There are several factors you need to consider to ensure meeting your hair color goal. Let’s take a look at them.

The Best Hair Dyes For Natural Hair – Buying Guide to Pick The Best

• Determine Your Skin’s Undertone

To choose the best hair dyes for natural hair, you need to determine your skin undertone, and then pick a shade that neutralizes it. For example, if your skin has yellow hues, you have a warm undertone; a pinkish hue means you have a cool undertone, and if you can’t tell, that means you might have a neutral undertone. Blonde shades like platinum, sand, and beige go well with warm undertones. For cool undertones, you can pick shades like gold, caramel, and amber. For neutral undertones, pick shades like rust, copper, and amber. It’s important to choose hair dyes that are gentle on natural hair to maintain its health and integrity.

• Choose Your Style

Before starting with the coloring process of your natural hair, you will find choices between highlights, lowlights, ombre, global, or balayage. If you are confused about which one to choose, consult a professional like a hair stylist who will guide you through and help you make the right choice. This will also help you pick the right hair dye that will go well with your natural hair.

• Check The Ingredients

Look for products enriched with nourishing ingredients like avocado, shea butter, glycerin, and olive oil. These ingredients will provide moisturization to your hair while coloring it. Read the product label thoroughly and avoid buying products that contain PPD, ammonia, sulfates, and other harmful ingredients that might cause allergic reactions.

• Pick Permanent Or Temporary Hair Colors

There are different types of hair color treatments available on the market. If you want to experiment with a color for a few weeks, go for semi-permanent hair colors. But if you want to cover grays or maintain a hair color for a long time, choose a permanent hair color. In the case of permanent hair color, you will only have to get root touch-ups every few weeks to match your roots to the rest of your hair.

Note: No matter which hair dye you choose, professionals recommend that you perform a patch test on your arms by using one drop of the hair color. If your skin develops allergic reactions to the ingredients, stop using the product immediately.
So, now that you are aware of the best hair dyes for natural hair and how to pick the right one. Now, let’s get into how to dye natural hair. Before dyeing natural hair at home, you need to be well aware of the process and the steps of coloring your hair. Here are a few tips.

How To Dye Natural Hair At Home

• Wash your hair 3-4 days before dyeing your hair. This will ensure that your hair is free from dirt, oil, and buildup but has enough oils to protect it during the dyeing process.

• Perform a patch test to ensure that the hair color does not cause any allergic reactions.

• Protect your clothing and skin by draping your shoulders with an old towel and applying petroleum jelly to prevent staining your skin.

• Wear the gloves provided in the coloring kit and divide your hair into equal and manageable sections.

• Bleach and tone your hair if you are going for a pastel or a blonde shade.

• Now that you are all set, prepare the dye by following the instructions given in the package.

• Apply the dye to your hair shafts, starting from the mid-lengths to the ends. Make sure that the dye is saturated throughout the hair.

• Repeat the process and then comb the dye through your hair.

• Use the applicator bottle’s nozzle and apply the dye to the hair roots.

• Wrap the hair sections with pieces of aluminum foil. Wrap a towel around your head or wear a shower cap for better results.

• Allow the color to develop and let it sit for at least 20-45 minutes.

• Rinse the dye thoroughly with lukewarm water. Do not use shampoo or hot water.

• Apply the conditioner in the kit to your hair and keep it for 2 to 3 minutes. Wash it off with cool water. You can also use any color-safe conditioner.

Infographic: Tips To Select The Right Hair Dye For Natural Hair

There is an overwhelming number of hair color shades available on the market. Which of those is for you? Of course, it depends on what you are in the mood for. But there are a few things that you might want to consider before narrowing down on one shade. The infographic below will give you some tips on how you can select the right shade to dye your hair. Take a peek!

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best dye for natural African-American hair?

The Soft Sheen Carson Dark And Lovely Fade-Resistant Rich Conditioning Color and the Shea Moisture Nourishing Moisture-Rich Color Creme are suitable for natural African-American hair.

What color can I dye my black hair without bleaching?

If you want to dye your black hair and change its look without bleaching, go for magenta, red, deep red, or violet shades.

What color can I dye my dark brown hair without bleaching?

You can dye dark brown hair without bleaching it if you go for hair dyes specially crafted for dark brown or any other dark-colored hair.

Can you color dark hair without bleaching it?

Yes, you can color dark hair without bleaching it if you use temporary or semi-permanent hair color.

For natural hair, which hair dye is safe for pregnant women?

A hair dye with natural and plant-based ingredients and the least chemical ingredients is safe for pregnant women. The Clarins Natural Instincts hair color is perfect. It has an ammonia-free formula with 80% natural ingredients.

What is the longest-lasting hair dye for natural hair?

If you’re looking for long-lasting hair dye, go for permanent hair colors. Lime Crime, Schwarzkopf, dpHue, and Just 5 have some excellent options.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

StyleCraze articles are backed by expert opinions and suggestions from certified professionals. Oyendrila Kanjilal, the author, is a hair color enthusiast and has sifted through hundreds of products and reviews and consulted with hair care professionals to ensure nothing but the best picks for the readers.

Was this article helpful?

Reviewer Author Editor Fact Checker

Leata A. WilliamsBoard-certified Trichologist

 

Leata A. Williams is the founder of Mane Theory, Inc. She is a L’ Oreal trained licensed cosmetologist who began styling hair at a very young age. Leata’s love for hair came about once she realized the versatility of styles that can be done.

Read full bio of Leata A. Williams

Oyendrila KanjilalCommerce Writer

 

Oyendrila holds a master's degree in English Literature from the University Of Calcutta, West Bengal, and is a certified skin care coach. As a beauty and lifestyle writer with two years of experience, she writes about everything that the modern woman needs to know about grooming and self-care.

Read full bio of Oyendrila Kanjilal

Shiboli ChakrabortiCommerce Editor

Shiboli has a master’s degree in English literature from The English and Foreign Languages University, Hyderabad, and is a certified skincare coach with four years of experience. As a commerce editor, she guides her team members on the best practices to create crisp and authentic content.

Read full bio of Shiboli Chakraborti

Anjali SayeeAssociate Editor

Anjali is an associate editor at StyleCraze. She specializes in hairstyles and hair and skin care and has written over 200 articles in these domains. She has 7 years of experience, and her philosophy about hair and skin care is simple: if you love and care for it, it will be healthy.

Read full bio of Anjali Sayee