15 Best Natural-Looking Mascaras, Cosmetologist Picks (2024)

If you are looking for the best natural-looking mascara available on the market, then you are definitely in the right place. Most people desire the no-makeup makeup look, and to ace it, you need natural-looking makeup products for an enhanced beauty. The best way to begin is to start with your eyes and grab the perfect natural mascara.

Natural mascaras are expertly-crafted with ingredients that are not harsh on the delicate eyelashes and help strengthen them. However, the market is filled with many options, and finding the right fit might be difficult. This article intends to make your search missions easier.

Here, we have made a list of the 15 most natural-looking mascara for your lashes that you must consider including in your makeup collection right away. Scroll down to check out the list.

Top 15 Best Natural-Looking Mascara For Amazing Eyelashes

1. Best For Daily Use: Aliver 4D Silk Fiber Lash Natural Mascara

This waterproof formula creates thicker fanned lashes with just one coat of its clump-free formula. The smooth and creamy formula paired with a natural bristle brush instantly boosts your lashes with length and volume and ensures that it stays that way all day long. This clean mascara is also easy to remove with some warm water or makeup remover. The hypoallergenic formula also makes it safe for contact lens wearers and those with sensitive eyes.

Quick Tip

If you wear contact lenses, press a damp warm cloth on the lashes to warm and soften the product and follow up with a makeup remover for easy removal.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

More than 10,625 Amazon users have vouched for this amazing product.

2. Best Travel-Size: Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Super Curling & Lifting Mascara

Sweep on this unique formula from Benefit Cosmetics for voluminous, healthier-looking lashes. The travel size mascara comes in cute packaging with a Hook ‘n’ Roll brush. You can think of it as a roller for your eyelashes that helps to separate and lift your wispy lashes. Formulated with serin and provitamin B5, the formula conditions your lashes and gives a satin finish. The fullest volumizing feature offers visible lift and long-lasting curl up to 12 hours so there’s no need for repeated touch-ups. Check out this video for a detailed review of a tester’s experience with the water-resistant product.

Quick Tip

Avoid clumping and go from the base to the tip to evenly spread the mascara and get thicker and fuller lashes.

3. Best Volumizing: Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara

This dermatologist-tested, natural mascara from Tarte is your ideal companion for lashed definition. The smart mascara is the perfect pick if you want natural-looking lashes with understated drama. Ideal for daily use, it works to promote healthier eyelashes by strengthening dry and brittle ones to prevent lash loss. It is truly a smart mascara in every sense as it addresses and treats the lash concerns while giving you lengthy and voluminous lashes. Formulated using skin-invigorating ingredients such as vitamin C, Amazonian clay, provitamin B5, carnauba wax, and rice bran wax, the lash-conditioning properties of this product are highly beneficial. Reviews on online forums attest that it is truly a gem for anyone looking for some added benefits in their everyday mascara.

Quick Tip

Using a finer brush for this mascara will do you good in avoiding any excess application.

Pro tip: Using a finer brush for this mascara will do you good in avoiding any excess application.

	Aliver 4D Silk Fiber Lash Natural Mascara Best For Daily Use	Benefit Cosmetics Roller Lash Super Curling & Lifting Mascara Best Travel-Size	Tarte Cosmetics Gifted Amazonian Clay Smart Mascara Best Volumizing
	Buy Now	Buy Now	Buy Now
Color	Black	Black	Black
Dimensions	-	3.4 x 0.5 x 3.2 inches	0.87 x 5.75 x 1.18 inches
Weight	-	0.3 Ounces	0.8 Ounces
Rating
Reviews	10,625	2,428	591
Price	$9.99	$24.24	$24

4. Best Hypoallergenic: Glossier Lash Slick Natural Looking Mascara

For all you lazy gals, this product from Glossier requires very little maintenance. Expect some added length and volume that enhances your natural lashes without clumping. Designed with teeny-tiny fibers, this dermatologist-tested mascara lifts and locks each lash in its place for natural beauty enhancement. The natural formula is also water-resistant but not waterproof which means some warm water will do the trick when you need to hit the bed at the end of a busy day. The non-irritating formula is suitable for sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. It is also not tested on animals, making it an ideal cruelty-free option.

Quick Tip

Since the product is water-resistant and not waterproof, try staying away from warm water as it may wash off instantly.

5. Best Nourishing: IT Cosmetics Tightline 3-in-1 Black Primer – Eyeliner – Mascara

A lash primer and eyeliner that also works as a mascara, we now understand why this product is raved by beauty bloggers everywhere. This peptide-infused mascara is designed by plastic surgeons to coat your lashes right from the roots to the tip for an instant lash lengthening effect. Infused with hydrolyzed collagen, jojoba oil, biotin, chamomile, amino acids, proteins, and antioxidants, it offers ultra-conditioning by nourishing your lashes for better results. Unlike your normal mascaras, the groundbreaking skinny mascara wand coats even the first ⅓ third of the lashes with a soft black shade to give you the look of a fuller lash line.

Quick Tip

You can apply a layer of primer under this mascara to enhance and pop up the look of your eyelashes.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

This product has received 910 reviews from customers on Amazon, indicating its popularity and reliability.

6. Best Buildable Formula: Beautify Beauties Easy On The Eyes Sensitive Mascara

This natural-looking mascara is perfect for daily use whether you are heading off to work or Sunday brunch with your girls. The gentle hypoallergenic formula is made with natural ingredients and suitable for the most sensitive eyes and contact lens wearers. Carefully designed using natural clays and waxes, it strengthens and nourishes the lashes for a smudge-free look. The highly pigmented formula also makes it possible to create varied looks ranging from subtle to the most dramatic eye makeup look. This is one of the best natural looking mascaras has garnered several positive reviews online as it is easy to wash off with soap and water or your favorite makeup remover.

7. Best Even Application: Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara

Next on our list of the best natural-looking mascara is Covergirl’s Clump Crusher. Despite its claim of giving dramatic volume, this mascara works great to create natural-looking lashes. The fine bristles help build volume without clumping by beautifully separating each lash with a single stroke for smooth application. The curved brush design ensures that the lashes are covered from root to tip with natural fibers to give the right volume and build. Ethically-conscious reviewers highly recommend this clean mascara as it does not undergo animal testing.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

This product is so liked by shoppers that it has gained over 5,051 great reviews on Amazon.

8. Best Clump-Free: Maybelline New York Lash Discovery Waterproof Mascara

This mascara is designed with an exclusive lash-catching mini brush to get perfectly defined and separated lashes from root to tip. Reviewers rave about the unique design of the brush that ensures there are no clumps or globs. A few upward strokes give you lengthened and curved lashes to define the best feature of your face — your eyes. The smudge-proof waterproof formula is also ophthalmologist-tested and contact lens-safe.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

There are more than 5,667 Amazon reviews attesting to the quality of the product and endorsing its value.

9. Best For All-Day Wear: Ecco Bella FlowerColor Natural Mascara

This clean mascara is perfect for a subtle natural look for everyday wear. Made with clay and flower cutins, the smooth all-natural mascara gives fuller longer-looking lashes without clumping. The natural mascara is specially formulated for sensitive eyes and is easy to apply and remove without scrubbing. Reviews on online forums highly praise its convenient mirror tube with a uniquely designed brush that coats and separates each lash. The natural formula is also free of parabens, fragrance, and gluten. It is also not tested on animals, making it a favorite among ethically-conscious makeup lovers. It is the most natural-looking mascara with great buildable coverage.

10. Best Natural Finish: Perricone MD No Mascara Mascara

The No Mascara Mascara has spawned into a fan favorite, making it into our list of the best natural-looking mascara. Scientifically formulated using biotin and neuropeptides, the 2-in-1 lash treatment and mascara conditions and strengthens the lashes. Suitable for everyday wear, it gives fuller and longer-looking lashes. If that’s not enough, the curling mascara features a deep color that is universally suited for all skin tones. Additionally, it is not tested on animals, making it an ideal cruelty-free mascara.

11. Best Ophthalmologist-Tested: Clinique Naturally Glossy Mascara

Just like the name suggests, Clinique’s Naturally Glossy Mascara does exactly what it says: It delivers excellent lash separation and definition. The natural mascara comes in a sleek silver tube-sized bottle with a long applicator brush. Several reviewers recommend its gel-based formula that naturally lengthens eyelashes with a glossy finish. It is available in 2 shades — Jet Black and Jet Brown.

12. Best Strengthening: Wander Beauty Unlashed Volume and Curl Mascara

Finding the best natural mascara can be quite a struggle when you are spoiled with choices. However, this subtle lash enhancement product from Wander Beauty is sure to be a hit with its long-lasting formula and natural ingredients. Expect fuller-looking lashes with its unique fine-toothed comb that separates and coats lashes from root to tip while keeping them natural. The dome-tip mascara wand with staggered bristles can be angled in different ways to create a range of looks from subtle to the most dramatic. This ophthalmologist-tested, natural mascara is infused with a blend of lash-loving ingredients such as peach leaf and licorice root extract, trehalose, plus vitamins A, C, and E that helps condition and strengthen lashes while preventing fallouts.

13. Best Easy-To-Remove: Neutrogena Healthy Volume Mascara

Neutrogena’s mascara is your ultimate companion to create natural voluminous lashes. The olive oil-infused natural formula plumps and conditions your lashes from the inside out. But most importantly it won’t smudge, flake, or clump, giving you naturally defined and healthy-looking lashes in just one sweep. The light mascara is available in 4 different colors and waterproof and non-waterproof formulas to choose from.

14. Best For All Day Wear: Vivienne Sabó Paris – Mascara Cabaret Premiere

4.1

Image: Vivienne Sabó Paris

BUY ON AMAZON | $13.95

Buy on Walmart

Pleasingly chameleonic, Vivienne Sabó Paris’s mascara Cabaret Premiere is the perfect everyday companion for your eyes. It provides defined lashes with just one coat and creates a voluminous, lushly textured, and lustrous effect. In addition, the lightweight formula doesn’t clump or transfer to achieve feathery lashes. Reviewers attest that the mascara is easy to remove with a makeup remover without affecting the lash lines.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It has received over 6,489 rave reviews on Amazon, proving it is a mass favorite.

15. Best Nourishing: BareMinerals Love Every Lash Micro Defining Mascara

The one thing that caught our attention with this bareMinerals mascara is the slim wand and tiny bristles it comes with. The unique design of the wand helps provide a soft definition and catches every lash and coats it from root to tip including the hard-to-reach bottom and corner lashes. Formulated using fortifying ingredients, it helps nourish and condition lashes. The jet black formula is ideal to create fluffy lashes by fanning out each one to give you the desired look.

Below, take a look at our detailed buying guide for most natural-looking mascaras.

Buying Guide For Natural-Looking Mascara

How Do I Choose The Right Mascara?

Choosing the right mascara depends on various factors. Let’s take a look at them:

• The shape of the brush: The design of the brush plays a major role in how your lashes look after applying the mascara. Brushes come in different shapes and sizes. For natural-looking lashes, opt for one that gives the right dramatic volume and length without clumping.

• Formula: Unlike before, you now get innovative formulas that are enriched with natural ingredients. Not only are they safe for sensitive eyes, but some formulas also help strengthen and nourish your lashes by reducing fallouts. But it is safer to opt for a dermatologist-tested or expert-recommended mascara if you have sensitive eyes. Then there are those formulas that are specially designed for long-lasting wear or feature a clear texture that is more suitable for no-makeup makeup looks.

How To Apply Natural-Looking Mascara?

Below are the steps you need to follow when applying a natural-looking mascara:

• Curl your eyelashes using an eyelash curler of your choice. Start by keeping the curler at the base of your upper lashes. Close and hold it in place for a few seconds.

• Next, get the appropriate amount of product on the wand and coat your lashes from root to tip in a wriggling motion.

• If you wish for dramatic volume or length, repeat the above step until you get the desired degree of length and volume.

• Once the mascara has completely dried, you can opt for curling your lashes again with a lash curler for better-looking lashes.

How Can I Make My Mascara Look Natural?

First and foremost, choose a mascara that doesn’t clump or flake. For a more natural look, make sure you apply no more than 3 coats of mascara on your lashes. The most common mistake that most people make is using an old or expired product that has more chances of drying up and flaking, giving you a look that is far from natural lashes. Also, make sure to avoid using a primer if you want natural-looking lashes.

Infographic: How To Choose A Natural-Looking Mascara

A natural-looking mascara is ideal for people who want to enhance their lashes without creating a dramatic, ‘fake’ look. It offers a subtle enhancement that can be built up for the desired volume. But with so many options, how do you choose the best one? Check out the below infographic for tips to select a natural-looking mascara for your lashes.

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the healthiest mascara for your eyelashes?

Many mascaras are formulated using natural ingredients that strengthen and nourish lashes such as Benefit Cosmetics roller lash mascara, Tarte Cosmetics smart mascara, and IT Cosmetics tightline mascara.

What is the safest mascara to use?

If you have got sensitive eyes, then it would be best to go for a hypoallergenic and fragrance-free formula. Many mascaras are specially formulated without any non-irritant ingredients which makes them safe for sensitive eyes.

Why does my mascara always look clumpy?

Mascara can clump for a few reasons. The first reason being taking too much product on the wand. Another reason for clumps could be applying multiple coats of mascara too quickly.

Is clear mascara better for your lashes?

Clear mascara is the ideal choice if you want more natural-looking lashes with zero drama. They look just like your lashes, but only better.

Does brown mascara look more natural?

Yes. Brown shade naturally complements the skin tone and makeup effortlessly. As a result, it looks more natural and subtle.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

Srijita De, who authored this article is passionate about keeping up with the newest trends in makeup. She understands that mascara is an indispensable tool in one’s makeup arsenal. She conducted extensive research to list down the above selection of the best ones for you. She checked user feedback, considered the formulation of the products to prepare the list.

Was this article helpful?

Reviewer Author Editor Fact Checker

Angela JacksonLicensed Cosmetologist

 

Angela Jackson is a Maryland board-certified cosmetologist with over 28 years of experience. She received her cosmetology education from Dudley Beauty College in Washington, DC. She has trained under various hair and makeup artists and served bridal and in-salon clients and worked on various photoshoots and branding events.

Read full bio of Angela Jackson

Srijita DeCommerce Writer

 

Srijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world.

Read full bio of Srijita De

Srijani Roy Chowdhury Associate Commerce Editor

Srijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant.

Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury

Madhumati ChowdhuryAssociate Editor

Madhumati is an associate editor with seven years of professional experience. She has previously worked as an editor, proofreader, and a writer with various organizations, helping her navigate through the various facets of content creation and refinement with ease.

Read full bio of Madhumati Chowdhury