15 Best Expert-Recommended NYX Eyeshadows Of 2024
Show off those perfectly stylized eye pics with these fantastic products from NYX.
Nyssa GreenMakeup Artist
Nyssa Green is an Emmy award winning makeup artist and a trusted beauty and lifestyle expert with over 20 years of experience. Her diverse portfolio of clients includes celebrities from all walks of life, like Alicia Keys, Bono, Jane Fonda, Vickie Winans, Jermaine Dupri, several US Presidents, authors, and politicians.
Read full bio of Nyssa Green
Baishali is a beauty and lifestyle writer and holds a master's degree in English from Assam University. She specializes in makeup and fashion and is also a certified Style and Image Consultant. Prior to this, she was a part of a digital marketing company in Kolkata where she wrote stories on travel, beauty, and home décor.
Read full bio of Baishali Bhattacharya
Experience: 3 yearsSrijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant.
Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury
Experience: 2 yearsSrijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world.
Read full bio of Srijita De
Image: StyleCraze Design Team
The best NYX eyeshadow (or eyeshadows rather, as this brand has quite a few excellent eyeshadows to offer) is rated so highly because of a number of reasons: firstly, they are formulated expertly to give you seamless textures with long wear. Secondly, you can find eyeshadows in a wide variety of colors. Thirdly, NYX eyeshadows are vegan and cruelty-free and are safe for even sensitive skin. Doesn’t all this sound fantastic? Go ahead and take a look at the top 15 NYX eyeshadows that can help you grab the spotlights with just a single swipe.
In This Article
15 Best NYX Eyeshadows Of 2024
1. Best For Romantic Dates:NYX Professional Makeup Ultimate Shadow Palette – Phoenix
The Ultimate Shadow Palette by NYXoffers you the perfect look for late-night parties, everyday office casuals, or romantic dates. The rainbow-inspired palette contains 16 bold shades, from smokey gray and navy tones to sizzling orange and berry hues. It also features various finishes – metallics, mattes, shimmers, and satins. Everything you need to look like timeless beauty!
Pros
- Seamless, natural finish
- Blends perfectly
- Richly pigmented
- Value for money
- Allergy-tested
Cons
- Chalky
"I like the buttery and pigmented shades of this eyeshadow palette. The colors stay put through long shifts and make my eyes appear vibrant. They are also easy to remove."
Pro Tip
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
There are more than 28,181 Amazon reviews attesting to the quality of the product and endorsing its value.
2. Best Long-Lasting Formula:NYX Professional Makeup Ultimate Shadow Palette – Warm Neutrals
If you are more of a neutral color person, this gorgeous eyeshadow palette is ideal for you. It features 16 colors, which range from soft matte to shimmer shades and suit most skin tones.The long-lasting formula is super blendable and can help achieve an intense makeup look. This product is travel-friendly and suitable for on-the-go applications or touch-ups.
Pros
- Hypoallergenic
- Blends easily
- Value for money
- Easy to apply
- Suitable for all skin tones
- Compact packaging
Cons
- None
Quick TipWhy We Think It's Worth Buying
With over 28,181 reviews, this product has become a fan favorite among users.
3. Best For Dramatic Eyes:NYX Professional Makeup Swear By It
The Swear By It by NYX Professional Makeup features a whopping 40 shades. It contains cool and warm colors, which help create bold, dramatic eyes. The shades are buildable, super blendable, and easy to apply. Mix and match these stunning shades to create a flattering look for any event. This is the perfect eyeshadow palette if you are looking to flaunt a duo-chrome eyeshadow look! It is sure to uplift your enhanced features and make some heads turn around.
Pros
- Blends easily
- Buildable
- Seamless application
- Comes in 40 shades
Cons
- The dark shades are not richly pigmented
"This eyeshadow palette is great. The shades are easy to apply and does not cause any fallout. I layer the shades as per my needs. They hold up well and don't look flaky."
| NYX Professional Makeup Ultimate Shadow Palette - Phoenix | NYX Professional Makeup Ultimate Shadow Palette - Warm Neutrals | NYX Professional Makeup Swear By It | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Color | Phoenix | Warm Neutrals 1 Count | Multi |
| Dimensions | 0.71 x 3.9 x 3.78 inches | 7.09 x 38.98 x 37.8 inches | 0.48 x 8.85 x 5.75 inches |
| Weight | 0.32 Ounces. | 0.46 Ounces | 10.75 Ounces |
| Rating | |||
| Reviews | 28,181 | 28,181 | 1,426 |
| Price | $16.18 | $13.76 | $35 |
4. Best Must-Have:NYX Professional Makeup Lid Lingerie Shadow Palette
This cute eyeshadow palette by NYX is a must-have in your vanity. It features six creamy matte shades that blend seamlessly and melt into your skin for a stunning look. This eyeshadow palette contains neutral brown shades for a warm smokey eye, a classy peach shade for that extra depth, and a lavender shade to add a little pop of color. The creamy formula of the shades gives exceptional results, as they can also be used to contour and highlight your face.
Pros
- Sheer formula
- Blends easily
- Matte finish
- Can be used for highlighting and contours
Cons
- None
"This matte eyeshadow palette gives me a natural look. The shades have buildable coverage and help me get my desired finish. I like that I can also create smokey eye looks with the shades."
Pro Tip5. Best Color Payoff:NYX Ultra Pearl Mania – Nude
This loose eyeshadow by NYX offers a superior color payoff. It can also be used on your cheeks and nose as a highlighter. This vegan formula known for its blendability, is made of a finely milled mineral that provides a long-lasting and high-impact color. The rich pigments blend easily and offer full coverage with a metallic shimmery finish. Nyssa Green adds, “You can also wet these and use them as liners.”
Pros
- Easily blendable
- Provides full coverage
- Metallic finish
- Richly pigmented
- Doubles up as a highlighter
Cons
- Maycauseitchiness
"The shades in this eyeshadow palette have great pigmentation. They stay for a long time without being flaky. I use the shades sparingly because a little goes a long way."
6. Best Insta-Ready Look:NYX Professional Makeup Perfect Filter Shadow Palette – Rustic Antique
The Rustic Antique by Nyx Professional Makeup Perfect Filter range gets you ready for that classy insta-ready look in minutes. It features a shade range of 10 warm hues, which suits all skin tones. These shades come in matte, glitter, and satin finishes. They are richly pigmented and offer full coverage in a single swipe. The lightweight formula does not feel chalky or powdery. The shades of this eyeshadow palette are easily blendable and help create a striking look.
Pros
- Blends easily
- Richly pigmented
- Provides full coverage
- Lightweight
- Easy to remove
- Value for money
- Available in 10 shades
Cons
- None
"I like the vibrant colors in this eyeshadow palette. They stay on my lids with minimal fallout. The shades are rich and buildable and offer both matte and subtle shimmer options."
7. Best Metallic Finish:NYX Professional Makeup Cosmic Metals Shadow Palette
This stunning eyeshadow palette by NYX features six versatile shades of gold, mauve, and plum. The richly pigmented shades with a shimmery rich metallic finish do not form chunks. The finely milled texture glides smoothly on your eyelids and is easy to apply. The shades are highly pigmented; therefore, the makeup process does not test your patience!
Pros
- Metallic finish
- Smooth application
- Easy to apply
Cons
- None
"This eyeshadow palette has shades with rich pigmentations. They apply smoothly and do not appear flaky. The shadows blend seamlessly and have great staying power."
8. Best Smokey Eye Look:NYX Professional Makeup Smokey Fume Shadow Palette
This shadow palette by NYX Professional Makeup features six super pigmented shades of white, black, blue, cream, and mauve. It helps you achieve an out-of-the-world smokey eye look. The shades are cool-toned and blend easily to give a shimmery, matte finish. If you’re in the world of makeup artistry, this eyeshadow shade palette is a must-have!
Pros
- Blends easily
- Shimmery matte finish
- Cute packaging
- Value for money
Cons
- None
"This eyeshadow palette has long-lasting colors. I apply these colors as per my needs and they don't cause redness or irritation. I often use the dark and dramatic colors for creating smoky eye looks."
9. Best Highly-Pigmented:NYX Professional Makeup Mystic Petals Shadow Palette
The NYX Professional Makeup Mystic Petals Shadow Palette is inspired by night-blooming flowers. It features earthy neutrals to fun electric shades in shimmery, matte, and satin finishes. These eyeshadow colors are highly-pigmented, super blendable, easy to apply, non-chalky,and add intensity to your makeup game. These expertly crafted shades and formula will truly elevate your makeup game!
Pros
- Non-chalky
- Blends easily
- Easy to apply
Cons
- None
"This palette has vibrant shades. They are easy to apply and cause minimal fallout. The colors stay for a long time and blend well for extended wear."
10. Best Shimmer-Less Formula:NYX Professional Makeup – Lap Dance
This subtle nude matte shade by NYXProfessional Makeup is perfect for a formal everyday look. It blends seamlessly with just a single swipe. The shimmer-less formula stays for long and offers a matte finish. Nyssa Green, an Emmy award-winning makeup artist and founder of The Green Room says, “This is a great contour color.”
Pros
- Blends easily
- Offers full coverage
- Richly pigmented
- Matte finish
Cons
- May cause irritation
"This eyeshadow gives me a consistent eye look. It applies smoothly and masks the veins on my lids. It works really well over a primer."
11. Best For All Skin Tones:NYX Professional Makeup Diamonds & Ice Please! Shadow Palette
Make bold statements at parties, night outs, and festive occasions with the NYX Professional MakeupDiamonds & Ice Please! Shadow Palette offers six rich shades. The shades are easily blendable, highly-pigmented, and provide full coverage in just one swipe. They provide a shimmery finish, last all day without fading, and complement all skin tones. The exceptional results make your eye makeup pop and leave you with eye-catching shades!
Pros
- Blends easily
- Provides full coverage
- Buildable
- Fade-proof
- Value for money
Cons
- The shimmer spreads
12. Best Buildable Formula:NYX Professional Makeup Soft & Rosy Shadow Palette
The NYX Professional Makeup Soft & Rosy Shadow Palette features six highly-pigmented shades that help achieve deep, dramatic eyes. The warm rose-tinted shades are ideal as transition shades for light to medium skin tones. The long-lasting, buildable formula glides onto your eyelids to offer a shimmery finish.
Pros
- Buildable
- Shimmery finish
- Blends easily
- Glides smoothly
Cons
- May cause irritation
"This eyeshadow palette has beautiful colors. They blend well and are nicely pigmented. They are easy to apply and do not make my eyelids feel heavy."
13. Best For Night Parties:NYX Professional Makeup Ultimate Shadow Palette
This limited edition shadow palette contains 16 neutral shades in matte, metallic, and satin finishes. The shades offer buildable coverage and a rich color payoff that lasts for hours. This eyeshadow can also be used to contour and highlight your face. The easily blendable formula helps create both day and nighttime makeup looks. You can create countless statement-making looks with these shades.
Pros
- Lightweight
- Waterproof
- Blends easily
- Buildable coverage
- Rich color payoff
- 16 neutral shades
Cons
- None
"The shades in this eyeshadow palette are long-lasting and give me vibrant color payoff. I often apply them after applying a concealer and primer on my eye lids. They are great for evening looks and weekend parties."
14. Best Travel-Friendly:NYX Professional Makeup Love In Rio Shadow Palette
This eyeshadow palette by NYX features three gorgeous shades and a handy two-sided applicator. The shades are richly pigmented, blend easily, smooth textured, and last all day. This product has compact packaging that is travel-friendly and ideal for a quick on-the-go look.
Pros
- Blends easily
- Easy to apply
- Smooth texture
- Includes a double-sided applicator
- Value for money
Cons
- None
"This NYX eyeshadow palette has vibrant colors. They stay on my eyelids without being patchy or flaky. I like that the shades blend seamlessly and give me a natural finish."
15. Best Lustrous:NYX Professional Makeup Prismatic Eyeshadow – Mermaid
This dazzling light sea green shade by NYX Professional Makeup is super lustrous and blends perfectly to offer a metallic finish. It provides good coverage in a single swipe. The soft, smooth texture makes you look like a timeless beauty for almost 12 hours.
Pros
- Blends easily
- Metallic finish
- Smooth texture
- Lasts for 12 hours
Cons
- None
"This eyeshadow gives me a lasting holographic effect. It is easy to apply and remains gentle on my eyes. It does not irritate my eyes and the color stays on all day."
The Bottom Line
Eyeshadows are very important when it comes to makeup and fashion! The brand NYX has created many eyeshadow palettes that makeup enthusiasts swear by! You can use the shades in these palettes for casual outings, romantic dinners, or extravagant parties. The NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette in Phoenix is a great choice for those who love to experiment with vibrant hues that blend effortlessly, while the NYX Swear By It has buildable shades that ideal for those who have to attend multiple events on the same day. If you are looking for versatile shades that can also be used for highlighting and contouring then try the NYX Lid Lingerie Shadow Palette. These eyeshadow palettes offer various finishes, including mattes, metallics, satins, and shimmers. However, while choosing the best NYX eyeshadow palette, you should choose the one that has super-blendable shades and can provide a seamless and radiant finish!
Why Trust Stylecraze?
The author, Baishali Bhattacharya, is certified in makeup techniques and writes research-based product reviews. She has compiled this list of the best NYX eyeshadows, considering their staying power and ability to provide a seamless texture. Besides extensively researching the product specifications, she has also scanned through hundreds of reviews to narrow down on this list.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is NYX eyeshadow smudge-proof?
No. NYX eyeshadows tend to smudge a little. So, apply the NYX eyeshadow primer on the lids to hold the shadows in place for a longer time.
How long does NYX eyeshadow last?
The shelf life of NYX eyeshadows is 12 months.
How long does it take for NYX eyeshadow to dry?
NYX eyeshadows take five seconds to dry and settle on the lids.
How do you use NYX liquid eyeshadow?
• Apply an eyeshadow primer to your lids.
• Dip the applicator in the liquid eyeshadow.
• Use small gentle strokes and apply the shadow on your lids evenly.
• Use your finger to blend the color on the crease area.
• If you want a bolder look, apply more shadow on the crease line and build the color with the base color.
• Use a fluffy brush to even out the harsh lines and develop a seamless eye look.
Read full bio of Nyssa Green
Read full bio of Baishali Bhattacharya
Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury
Read full bio of Srijita De
Community Experiences
Join the conversation and become a part of our empowering community! Share your stories, experiences, and insights to connect with other beauty, lifestyle, and health enthusiasts.