10 Best NYX Mascaras Of 2024, Recommended By A Makeup Artist

The best NYX mascara can volumize and lengthen your lashes in just a few strokes. NYX offers a line of high-quality mascaras that look after your skin while adding a touch of glam. It has been a well-loved brand among users for a while now. Its collection includes a variety of lash colors and not just the classic blacks and browns.

Mascaras are beauty products that play a pivotal role in your eye makeup looks. They enhance your eyes and let them do the talking. A few strokes of mascara can instantly add drama to your basic outfits. One thing to note is that NYX Cosmetics is vegan and never tests its products on animals, which makes them so popular amongst celebrities and influences alike. In this article, we have listed some of the best NYX mascaras after closely reviewing them. Go ahead and check them out now.

Top 10 NYX Professional Makeup Mascara + Reviews

1. Best Overall: NYX Professional Makeup Tinted Brow Mascara – Blonde

4.3

Image: Nyx Professional Makeup

BUY ON AMAZON | $6.99

Whoever out there is looking to make a statement with their eyebrows, look for NYX’s Tinted Brow Mascara- Blonde. This brow mascara is specifically designed to fill the brow gaps while keeping it soft and firm. The soft bristles can also be used to comb the arches to shape it after every makeup session. Use it over primers, base mascara, face powders, or eyebrow pencils to heighten up the intense eyebrow look.

Why We Think It's Worth Buying

It has gained over 23,453 positive reviews on Amazon, making it an all-time best-seller.

2. Best Waterproof: NYX Professional Makeup Doll Eye Mascara – Volume, Black

3.5

Now 19% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $16.95

Eyelashes that flutter like butterflies’ wings will make your pretty face look doll-like. That’s what the statement-making Doll Eye Mascara does to your eyes. The mascara extends the lashes and adds volume to it which can be easily mistaken for a lash extension. The waterproof formula keeps the fake lashes looking the same and just as real throughout the day so you don’t have to go for unnecessary retouches. Go for the NYX Doll Eye Mascara now and get wowed by the look! If you need more convincing, feel free to take a look at this YouTuber’s video on the merits and demerits of this lash enhancement product through a tester’s experience of using it.

3. Best Volumizing Mascara: NYX Professional Makeup Worth The Hype Mascara – Black

4.3

Now 24% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $8.97

This mascara justifies its name as it truly is worth all the hype. This eye makeup product is mainly designed to achieve both volume and length for short and sparse eyelashes. Nyx ‘Worth The Hype’ mascara is a cruelty-free eyelash color that coats every eyelash perfectly with the help of the tapered brush. The collection consists of natural black, brown, and some other shades to spice up your party looks with your bold lashes. Take a look at this video detailing a tester’s experience with the product to learn more.

4. Best Lightweight Formula: NYX Personal Makeup On The Rise Volume Liftscara – Black

4.4

Now 10% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $10.77

Add some highlights to those droopy eyes with NYX’s On The Rise Volume Liftscara. The mascara with a matte finish is not a party wear but regular office wear. A clinical survey conducted on the product has had 95% of the customers voting for an instant volume and 94% for an instant lash lift. The innovative applicator shaped partly hourglass and partly rounded helps the mascara spread evenly and gives an instant lift to the short lashes while adding up to the intensity of the look. You can also check this YouTube review detailing a tester’s experience with the product to know more about the result it delivers.

Pro Tip

Mattify the undereye area with some translucent powder to prevent the mascara from smudging and splashing onto the skin.

5. Best Highly Pigmented: NYX Professional Makeup Color Mascara – Blue

4.2

BUY ON AMAZON | $14.99

Bored of the same old black mascaras? The NYX Professional Makeup Color Mascara has come to your rescue with its cool and funky color ranges. The highly-pigmented mascara does everything that some of the best-colored mascaras would do— add volume, increase length, and splash a bright pop of color. The best part of this mascara is that just one coat is more than enough to bring out the most intensified look. You can also use this iconic makeup product to color the tips for an eye-opening effect on eyelashes. Reviewers on Amazon loved the color and the formula of this mascara.

6. Best Long-Lasting: NYX Professional Makeup Boudoir Mascara Collection – Pin-Up Tease

4

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.45

NYX Professional Makeup Boudoir Mascara Collection’s Pin-up Tease does live up to its name. The dark thick solution glides over the eyelashes to give it a more defined and voluminous shape. The packaging comes with an innovative applicator in the form of an arching comb-like wand that spreads the mascara evenly for a smudge-proof look, turning the eyelashes looking dark, thin, and long. Use Nyx’s pin-up tease mascara with an eyelash curler for the finest finish.

7. Best For Lengthening The Lashes: NYX Professional Makeup Double Stacked Mascara

4

Image: Nyx Professional Makeup

BUY ON AMAZON | $29.99

Now get the double effect at the price of one with NYX’s Double Stacked Mascara. It is a three-step lash-extending formula that nourishes the roots of the lashes while increasing their length and making them look dramatic and beautiful, giving them a false lash look. All you have to do is apply a light coat of the Double Stacked Mascara first and then follow it up with the Double Stacked Lash Fiber Lengthening Formula. Finally, add up another layer of the Double Stacked Mascara to seal the final look of your dramatic lashes. It delivers exceptio

nal results and makes your eyelashes appear thicker and longer.

Remember

Do not repeatedly pump the mascara while using it. Doing so will let air into the tube and dry out the formula fast. Instead, roll the wand inside the tube to load product onto the wand.

8. Best Cruelty-Free: NYX Professional Makeup Worth The Hype Waterproof Mascara

4.2

Now 7% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $8.97

Whether you want to darken the lashes, add more volume to them, or lengthen them, this second version of Worth The Hype mascara will meet all your eyelash needs. The NYX waterproof mascara has immense staying power, offers easy application, and works round-the-clock towards keeping the lashes looking fresh and the eyes bright. Effortless to apply because of the tapered tip of the brush and comfortable for everyday wear because of the soft texture; the buildable formula of this eye makeup product definitely deserves a special place in every girl’s kitty. Multiple reviewers recommend using this mascara as it does not flake or smudge.

Pro Tip

If you end up using too much mascara or if your eyelashes feel too heavy, just take a dry spoolie brush and run it through your lashes to remove the excess mascara without having to remove your eye makeup entirely.

9. Best Fast-Drying Formula: NYX The Skinny Mascara – Black

2.9

BUY ON AMAZON | $14.95

The highlight of this NYX skinny mascara is its skinny brush that coats the lashes from tip to end. The smallest, thinnest eyelash is also covered with the help of this black skinny mascara brush. This particular feature of this beauty product gives a lot of definition to the eyelashes, making them look lush and dense. Its water-resistant formula combined with the differently-designed brush turns the sensual quotient a notch higher.

10. Best For Short Lashes: NYX Professional Makeup Le Frou Frou Mascara

2.7

Now 40% Off

BUY ON AMAZON | $7.75

Available in 7 eye-catching formulas, this one is a must-have for every makeup lover. Le Frou Frou Mascara does its job perfectly, which is to add enough volume and length to the short lashes. A dense brush covers every small eyelash, even the ones on the corner of the eyes making them look fuller with a voluminous lash effect. What you will enjoy is how light and comfortable the product is and looks completely natural on the eyes. With this mascara, you’re getting yourself one of the best NYX professional mascaras for an all-day wear experience.

No brand has been 100% successful in satisfying their customers. There is good and bad in every product that a brand markets. NYX mascaras have had a very debatable review in that matter. Some of the points below will explain to you more about what should be kept in mind while buying an NYX Professional mascara.

How To Choose An NYX Mascara?

NYX mascaras have some good as well as not-so-good features that make the brand distinct from the others. Some of its distinguishing features given below will help you judge the products better.

• Affordable

NYX mascaras are good quality products available at a very cheap rate. This makes it a popular brand among the common people. Hence, you can get yourself a budget-friendly mascara that suits your price range better.

• Cruelty-free

NYX Professional Makeup is PETA-certified and acknowledged as a cruelty-free brand because they highly condemn testing on animals. Though a very small percentage of their products are not vegan and include ingredients like beeswax, the rest of the products are vegan and a treat for all animal lovers.

• Brush design

Whether tapered or hour-glass, NYX brushes are designed quite differently keeping the customer’s comforts in mind. These mascara wand designs are inculcated for an even coating of the product all over the lashes. Customers who are a stickler for comfort would definitely find the brushes wonderful to use. Choose a mascara with the kind of brush you are comfortable with.

• Hypoallergenic

Since NYX mascaras do not claim to be extra-sensitive, they might contain some ingredients not suitable for every skin type. So, if you are extremely sensitive to cosmetic products, make sure you check the ingredient list thoroughly and consult your dermatologist before introducing any new product. Try a patch test as well before you decide to use the mascaras.

NYX products are popular because they are affordable and cruelty-free. That is why most make-up lovers out there enjoy them. No product is perfect for everyone and some of the product shortcomings can be avoided if you know how to use them the right way. Let’s see how to do that, shall we?

How Do We Use NYX Mascara?

NYX Professional’s most popular mascaras can be applied in just a few simple steps.

1. Use a very small amount of smooth brow powder or primer for accurate lash separation, each one from the other.

2. Now shake the mascara bottle well before starting the coating process for the mascara to spread equally over the bristles.

3. Simply stroke the buildable formula over the lashes once or twice to witness the effect.

4. If you are not quite satisfied with the intensity, then keep building it up with more strokes for a darker, fuller effect.

Infographic: 6 Core Ingredients In NYX Mascaras

NYX mascaras help lengthen and volumize your lashes. They derive their effectiveness from some core ingredients that work in unison to elevate the look of your lashes. These elements also help to enhance the longevity and holding power of the mascaras. In the infographic below, we have listed 6 such ingredients and their benefits. Have a look.

Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team

Frequently Asked Questions

How good is NYX Mascara?

With 4.5 to 5 star ratings, NYX professional mascaras have been a cult-favorite for quite some time.

Is the NYX “Worth The Hype” mascara waterproof?

NYX’s “Worth The Hype” mascara collection is divided into two categories. One of them is a waterproof collection while the other isn’t.

Are NYX mascara products vegan?

All NYX mascaras aren’t vegan as some of them use animal-derived ingredients like beeswax, carmine, and others. Though, they have a lot of vegan options in their kitty too.

Is NYX mascara hypoallergenic and oil-free?

The product formulation on the NYX website does not mention anything about using any skin-sensitive ingredient but also does not claim to be hypoallergenic or oil-free.

Is NYX chemical-free?

No, NYX is not entirely chemical-free. However, most NYX products are free of harmful chemicals such as methylparaben, DEP, DBP, butylparaben, ethylparaben, or synthetic fragrances.

Why Trust StyleCraze?

The author of this post, Srijita De, has a deep interest in all things makeup. Mascaras are an important part of eye makeup, but with so many options available, it can be tough selecting a mascara brand. Chaitra recommends using NYX mascara because they are made with high-quality ingredients and come in a good variety of colors. She perused many products and their reviews on multiple forums to curate this list just for you. Each of these mascaras was chosen based on their color payoff, ingredients, brush bristles, additional benefits like adding volume or softness to lashes, and more.

Was this article helpful?

Reviewer Author Editor Fact Checker

Cha Cha WoskaCertified Makeup Artist

 

Cha Cha is a certified professional makeup artist, airbrush makeup artist, and beauty educator with over 20 years in the beauty industry. She is also the owner of Cha Cha Beauty Bar and has done extensive work in the bridal and special event categories.

Read full bio of Cha Cha Woska

Srijita DeCommerce Writer

 

Srijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world.

Read full bio of Srijita De

Rajeshwari DasAssociate Commerce Editor

Rajeshwari is a dedicated fitness and lifestyle enthusiast, deeply committed to enhancing our readers’ well-being and vitality. She has a master’s degree in Journalism & Mass Communication from the University of Calcutta.

Read full bio of Rajeshwari Das

Srijani Roy Chowdhury Associate Commerce Editor

Srijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant.

Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury