11 Best Expert-Approved Red Eyeshadows Of 2024
Play with colors to highlight your eyes with these waterproof and smooth red eyeshadows
Tommy is a New York-based makeup artist with over a decade of experience. He originally hails from Los Angeles and Tokyo and is largely inspired by color, organic life, and spirituality. Tommy has been featured in prestigious publications like Vogue Runway, Vogue Italia, Vanguard, Playbill, and Worldwide, among others.
Read full bio of Tommy Tafoya
Experience: 2 yearsSrijita De is a makeup and fashion enthusiast with a passion for empowering readers through practical tips and tricks to present their best selves with confidence. Armed with a postgraduate degree in English and Literature from the University of Calcutta, she has honed her writing skills and developed an in-depth understanding of the beauty and fashion world.
Read full bio of Srijita De
Experience: 3 yearsSrijani is an associate commerce editor with a master's degree in journalism and mass communication from the University of Calcutta, West Bengal. She is certified in makeup techniques and is also a certified style and image consultant.
Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury
Experience: 3 yearsAsmita De is an associate editor with over three years of experience. She graduated in English Literature from the University of Calcutta. She has collaborated with several digital companies and reputed publishing houses as an editor.
Read full bio of Asmita De
Image: Shutterstock
If you love switching up your eye makeup game, you can easily do so with the help of the best red eyeshadow in tow. If you may think red eyeshadow is something only celebrities can pull off, you could not be more wrong. You don’t have to sweat at the thought of putting on some red eyeshadow anymore.
Red adds that extra pop of color to your eyes and makes you look like the fierce diva you already are. With popular brands like KKW beauty and Fenti releasing red eyeshadows, the right red hue can fire up your glam quotient in a swipe. So, chuck the nude and pastel colors out and welcome the red eyeshadow with open and loving arms. Trust us; you won’t regret it. Here is our list of some of the top red eyeshadows out there that you can experiment with and add to your collection. Scroll down to check them all out.
In This Article
Top 11 Red Eyeshadows That Stay On All Day
1. Best Shade Range:Afflano Eyeshadow Palette-Coral Orange
The Coral Orange Afflano Eyeshadow Palette has a whole range of gorgeous shades of red eyeshadow. The palette has a selection of light and darker shades that can be used as per your mood. Being soft and blendable, its application is smooth and easy and popular with professional makeup artists. Using a combination of these excellent colors with matte and shimmer shades makes your eyes look more vivid and creates a natural, simple, or even whimsical look. They adhere well to the eyelids with a setting spray and offer great pigmentation giving you that stunning look that lasts the entire day. These highly-pigmented eyeshadows have an intense hue and are great for a statement-making look.
Pros
- High-quality ingredients that are anallergenic too
- A superb combination of matte and shimmer eyeshadow
- Cruelty-free product
Cons
- Pigment fades easily
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
It has gained over 6,651 positive reviews on Amazon, making it an all-time best-seller.
2. Best Matte Finish:ISMINE Single Eyeshadow Powder Palette
ISMINE Single Eyeshadow Powder as the name suggests comes in a single compact shade. This easy-to-carry single red eyeshadow is made using mica and mineral oil besides other ingredients and is highly-pigmented. Being waterproof, it lasts throughout the day and is a good highlighter to wear both while partying or even while working. With this eyeshadow, you can paint the town red, quite literally. Watch this YouTuber’s honest review to get a better idea about the product and its features.
Pros
- Available in bold color
- Comes in 13 vibrant shades individually
- Portable and comes in handy for touch up
- Works well on darker skin tones
Cons
- Leaves behind pigmentation even after washing
- Smudges easily
"The eyeshadow is highly-pigmented and gives a vibrant color to the eyes. It applies easily and gives a matte finish. It blends well and stays on the eyelids for long with minimal touch-ups."
Pro TipPair red eyeshadow with classic red lips to create a balanced and dramatic look.
3. Best Travel-Friendly:Stargazer EyeShadow-Deep Red
The Stargazer Eye Shadow comes in a single shade of the Stargazer Deep Red Eyeshadow. Pairing it with your Halloween costume can give you that fun looks from the movies. Its application is easy and smooth and lasts for long. This wonderful true deep red looks great when blended with shades of peaches and browns to give that striking and gorgeous look. This fiery red eye-catching shade is richly pigmented and is a great choice for dramatic makeup. Available in a small package, this sparkly red eyeshadow is travel-friendly and is a must-have in every woman’s makeup collection.
Pros
- Highly pigmented
- Pocket and travel-friendly
- Application is easy and smooth
Cons
- Leaves behind a faint color even after washing
- Size may be smaller
"The red shade is beautiful! It mixes well with the other shades and helps me create my unique eye looks. The best part is that the shade holds up well without any allergic reactions. I like its bold and clean finish."
Why We Think It's Worth Buying
More than 1,231 customers have given the product positive reviews on Amazon.
4. Best Shimmer Finish:NYX Ultimate Edit Eyeshadow Palette – Phoenix
The NYX Ultimate Edit Eyeshadow Palette Phoenix comes in six beautiful shades of matte and shimmer finish for the eyes. The rich formula enables easy application so you can create both a smokey red eyeshadow look or something simpler. Its shimmering highly pigmented colors are suitable for both dark and fair skin tones and stay on for long hours. This trendy palette of six superb red shades is so compact that it can be your travel companion on your vacations, coming in handy at times when you need a quick touch-up before entering a party. This brand is certified and acknowledged by PETA and takes pride in facilitating professional makeup artistry.
Pros
- Suitable for all skin tones
- Cruelty-free product
- Comes in vibrant metallic shades
Cons
- Fallout may be high
"This eyeshadow palette is a great addition to my makeup collection. The colors are vibrant and work well for my morning as well as evening makeup looks. They apply smoothly and look gorgeous when paired with other shades. I generally use a primer before applying the shades to enhance their staying powers."
5. Best Pigmentation:Bloody Mary Eyeshadow
Bloody Mary Eyeshadow as the name suggests, is indeed the actual red shade that you would expect. This is a highly-pigmented palette and is vegan by all means. This lusty red eyeshadow can be used in the dry powder form as well as in the form of a rich and creamy formula. It is light in weight and stays put for long hours. Applying this eyeshadow using a soft, blending brush will give your eyes the look you have been craving for.
Pros
- Highly pigmented
- Stays for long hours
- Vegan
Cons
- Color may vary slightly
"This eyeshadow has a rich pigmentation and is quite long-lasting on the eyes. It feels lightweight and comfortable on the eyes. It is quite versatile and can be used wet and dry."
Pro TipRed eyeshadow can make you look tired as it accentuates the bluish undertones in the under eyes, so never skip applying concealer under the eyes.
6. Best Blendable:Glazzi Waterlight Pro 63 Colors Eyeshadow Palette
Glazzi Waterlight Pro 63 Colors Eyeshadow Palette is a huge palette consisting of 63 stunning colors. Besides using this as an eyeshadow, you can apply it to your face, leg, and body too. “Start with the darkest color on the outside of your eye, and create your desired shape, blending it in. Next, place the red and blend it in. Lastly stamp a light color or shimmer in the inner corner for an easy but impactful eye,” says makeup artist, Tommy Tafoya. This eyeshadow palette gives you a look that lasts all day long with a creamy texture and minimal fallout. This highly pigmented eyeshadow with so many vibrant colors, is a must-have for all occasions be it for formal or casual.`
Pros
- Made with skin-friendly ingredients
- Easy to blend colors
- Crease-proof and fade-proof
Cons
- Some users may find the consistency of colors chalky
"I like the red shades in this eyeshadow palette. They help me create different makeup looks, both subtle and bold. There is not fallout and the shades stay intact throughout the day. I can layer different shades of red to create my perfect eye makeup look as well."
Pro TipTo get a next-level red smokey eye look, blend red eyeshadow with brown or black eyeshadow, creating a gradient.
7. Best Hypoallergenic:DE’LANCI Red Eyeshadow Palette
The DE’LANCI Red Eyeshadow Palette is an amazing palette with rich, highly pigmented, and smooth colors that stay true for long hours. It comes in a variety of 12 bright, haute shades of red, and is a must-have treasure for every woman. The shades of this eyeshadow palette glide smoothly on the lids and blend like a dream. In addition, the matte, metallic, and shimmer shades strictly adhere to your skin, giving you a perfect look that lasts all day.
Pros
- Highly pigmented
- Cruelty-free
- Hypoallergenic
- Suits all skin types and tones
Cons
- None
"The shades in this red eyeshadow palette stay throughout the day. They are pigmented and do not need much layering. The shades are quite beautiful and settle without any heaviness."
8. Best For Beginners:Maelstrom Red Eyeshadow Palette
The Maelstrom Red Eyeshadow Palette comes with 12 gorgeous red eyeshadow shades that make for a great gift for your loved ones. The warm shades have a soft, blendable texture, which makes this palette popular among professional makeup artists. “The variety of reds and more neutral-tones make this an excellent and versatile choice, particularly for beginners. With just these 12 colors, there are so many possible looks – ranging from subtle options to graphic powerhouse looks. You could even contour or blush with a palette like this,” says makeup artist, Tommy Tafoya. This palette of good red eyeshadows adheres well to the eyelids and lasts all-day long.
Pros
- Eyeshadows can be used as an eyeliner too
- High-quality ingredients take care of your and sensitive skin
- Disguises flaws beautifully
- Makeup artist-approved
Cons
- Large eyeshadow flakes could cause discomfort
"I like this red eyeshadow palette. It is great for Halloween makeup! It makes my eyes pop and adds a subtle glam to my overall makeup. The shades are quite pigmented and do not cause fallout. They blend well, even when I layer them with other shades."
9. Best Smooth Texture:Raspberry Glaze Red Eyeshadow
The Raspberry Glaze Eyeshadow gives a frosty, glossy finish and a brightening look to the eye. The matte shades give a smooth finish whereas the shimmery shades give that soft yet glamorous look. This glitter red eyeshadow palette can be used as a highlighter as well as, offering value for money. This gluten-free and cruelty-free, high-quality eyeshadow can be used both ways either wet or dry, making them convenient to use.
Pros
- Triple-milled pressed gives it a very fine and smooth texture
- Good pigmentation
- Compact size
- Cruelty-free product
Cons
- Quantity of product may be less
- Color may be lighter
"This raspberry shade is a beautiful red. I like its shiny finish! It has a rich color payoff that helps me create glamorous eye looks. I also like the texture of this eyeshadow."
10. Best Creamy Texture:DE’LANCI Red Pink Eyeshadow Palette
If you are someone who loves reds and pinks equally, this palette of 12 red and pink matte and shimmer shadows is perfect for you. The smooth, cream shadows blend easily, delivering a true color pay-off that lasts all day. Moreover, they are waterproof and have a long-lasting staying power, with no need of frequent touch-ups. The sturdy palette is travel-friendly and easy to use. The highly pigmented shades are great for creating your favorite celebrity-inspired looks in versatile shades and the product is also suitable for beginners.
Pros
- Smooth creamy texture
- Comes in 7 matte and 5 shimmer shades
- Travel-friendly
- Cruelty-free
- Vegan
Cons
- None
"This is a good eyeshadow shade for adding bold red to any eye makeup. It is highly pigmented and does not require much layering. I also like how it makes my eyes pop. It blends well and gives me a great color payoff."
11. Best Talc-Free:HUDA BEAUTY Rose Gold Eyeshadow Palette Remastered
The Huda Beauty Rose Gold Palette is different from the first edition of the same product. These shades are softer, offer great color payoff, and also include gold, brown and pink shades. This palette comes with 8 matte and 8 shimmer shades, 1 black liner, and one pearl shade to give you the perfect look. It is the best combo of gold and red eyeshadow.
Pros
- Paraben and sulfate-free
- Talc-free
- Creamy formula
- Comes with a big mirror
Cons
- Price is higher
"I've spent considerable time with this product and found its performance quite satisfactory overall, though it lacks some finesse in ease of use. It's reliable for what it's designed to do, but don't expect it to exceed expectations—it's a solid, middle-of-the-road option that can do with some improvements."
With such a wide variety of red eyeshadows available, choosing the perfect one for yourself is difficult. That is exactly why you should read on to get that perfect red eyeshadow look for all the glam you want to achieve!
How To Get Your Hands On The Best Red Eyeshadow- A Buying Guide
Choosing an eyeshadow shade that complements your skin tone is a given, as with any other makeup product. Here are a few things you may want to consider before purchasing one:
- Swatching makeup on your skin before purchasing it allows you to see what the color will look like on you.
- Research the product you have your eyes set on (extra points to you for reading this article) and read customer reviews. This should very well help you out while buying the best red eyeshadow for yourself.
- Watch tutorials on how to use a red eyeshadow as it is a tricky look to pull-off. Even though many celebrities make it look like a piece of cake, wearing a red eyeshadow wrong can quickly take you from looking hot and happening to scary and daunting.
- Using an eye primer is essential to give your eyeshadow color something to hold onto. A simple trick would be to apply a thin base layer first across your eyelid or give your lash line definition by brushing right along it.
Infographic: What To Keep In Mind While Choosing Red Eyeshadows
Red eyeshadows can add depth and intensity to accentuate your eye makeup look. But not all shades look flattering on everyone. If you need some help finding the right eyeshadow based on your skin tone and undertone, check out the infographic below. Illustration: StyleCraze Design Team
The Bottom Line
Red eyeshadow is a game changer! You can glam yourself up with the help of a red eyeshadow to attract eyeballs at a party. From glitters to pastels, there are many red eyeshadows available in the market that provide a stunning look. The Stargazer EyeShadow-Deep Red has a highly pigmented shade that adds a bold and dramatic touch to your makeup, while the NYX Ultimate Edit Eyeshadow Palette – Phoenix has a shimmery finish that is suitable for fair, medium, and dark skin tones. But if you are seeking a vegan formula that is lightweight, then try the Bloody Mary Eyeshadow. If you want the best of both worlds, there is nothing wrong with purchasing red eyeshadows that provide an effortlessly matte finish with a hint of shimmer. Moreover, when purchasing a red eyeshadow palette, you should only cater to products that have been created with high-quality ingredients.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is red eyeshadow bad for you?
No, it is not and depends on the way you wear it. Blending it well will give you the best possible results.
Does red eyeshadow look good?
Any makeup color that compliments your skin tone will look good ultimately.
Does red eyeshadow suit blue eyes?
Choosing the right shade of red like a warm coral would make your blue eyes pop and complement your outfit at the same time.
Does red eyeshadow suit brown eyes?
Choosing a color that compliments the brown color of your eyes is important. A copper-red would not only enhance your eyes but also make them look stunning.
Why does red eyeshadow irritate my eyes or cause red eyes?
Red eyeshadow usually consists of an allergen called carmine that gives it its red hue which may irritate some skin types. Do take care to read about what has gone into the makeup product you have chosen.
Which color lipstick pairs well with red eyeshadow?
Keeping the rest of your look simple along with a red eyeshadow works best. A nude or a light shade of brown on the lips would go well overall.
Why Trust StyleCraze?
Chaitra Krishnan, the author, enjoys makeup and has the lowdown on the eyeshadows you should own. She shares tips for choosing the best red eyeshadow in her buying guide and explains how to consider parameters such as the hue and user needs for a better experience. She compiled this list of the top products after conducting extensive research and reviewing numerous online reviews. Adding red eyeshadow to your makeup routine can give you that bold, sultry look.
Read full bio of Tommy Tafoya
Read full bio of Srijita De
Read full bio of Srijani Roy Chowdhury
Read full bio of Asmita De
Community Experiences
Join the conversation and become a part of our empowering community! Share your stories, experiences, and insights to connect with other beauty, lifestyle, and health enthusiasts.